Questioning

You fiddled with the hem of your blouse as Dean drove off. It was one thing to advertise to be able to do something, but another to actually do it. Sure you had a way with talking to people, but that didn't make you any less nervous.

What if I say the wrong thing and made it worse? What would Sam and Dean think of you then? But before you could question yourself anymore you heard your phone start to ring, you answered and instantly wish you hadn't.

"Y/n? You idjit, where the hell are you?" You heard Bobby's voice demand and you could tell he was worried.

"Hey Bobby.." you replied lamely. You saw both the boys look at your with worried and guilty expressions.

"Don't you hey Bobby me young lady, where are you?" he said sternly.

"I'm with Sam and Dean," you told him trying to sound reassuring.

"With Sam and Dean? After I and not to mention Dean told you no?" He said trying to sound angry but you could hear relief in his voice.

"Yeah.." You may be an adult now but that doesn't mean the guilt of doing something your not supposed to will disappear.

"Hand the phone to one of those idjits," he said not sounding as angry as before.

"Yes sir," you said and offered the phone to Sam, mainly because he wasn't the one driving. As Sam reached out to grab the phone, Dean took it and put it up to his ear.

"Hey there Bobster," he said as if nothing was wrong. Even though you couldn't hear Bobby's response, you had a feeling it wasn't going to be good. You and Sam both gave each other a look but stayed quiet and listened to as much as you could.

"I was thinking that she could help us out.....

That's why we're here.....

Well then I'm gonna teach her....

No no no, I'll make sure she comes back right after.....

and we won't stand in the way of that.....

Yeah I know, but I happen to be driving so maybe we can push this conversation to later.....

Yes, I promise, bye Bobby." Dean then hung up and handed you your phone back.

"Well? What'd he say?" You asked expectantly.

"You can stay until this hunt is over then you're going home and I'm sure you probably won't see us again," he said indifferently.

Your heart dropped at the thought of not seeing either brothers again. You might've just met Dean but it shocked you how comfortable you felt around him. You've just been reunited with Sam and so far your friendship seems to be even better than before he left.

But when you saw Sam's face drop, you decided right then and there that you would make damn sure you'd see them again.

"Just let anyone try and stop me," you said firmly. You noticed Dean eye you in surprise through the rearview mirror and gave you a smile which you returned.

Dean's POV

The rest of the drive was pretty quite after Y/n's statement, the three of you lost in your own thoughts. Soon enough you parked Baby at this guy's place and got out. You and Sammy were in the FBI uniforms, you stopped beforehand to get Y/n her own fake badge. She was currently wearing a white blouse with a black jacket and matching pencil skirt.

You took the lead and walked up to the door of the victims place. Once Y/n caught up to you and Sam, you made a joke about her being short and rang the doorbell. Soon enough a man opened the door, it was the Tobias guy.

"Hello sir," Sam said and all three of you flashed the man your fake FBI badges. "We'd like to as-" Sam tried to continue but the man cut him off.

"It's You guys again? I already told you I'm not answering anymore questions," Tobias said annoyed.

"We're sorry to bother you again, Mr. Evans, but as my partner was trying to say, it will only take a moment," Y/n said and you could tell she was trying to hide her own annoyance for the man. Tobias looked at her, probably just realizing she was there and seemed to think about it.

"No, the family I have left is inside, maybe some other time," he said with bitterly.

"We understand, but it'd be best if you answer our questions now and get them out of the way," she said gently while staying firm. Tobias seemed to weigh his options before sighing and nodding.

"Fine, but you'll have to give me a moment," he gave in, Y/n nodded understandingly and he went back inside.

"I told you I could do it," she said quietly to you and Sam with a proud smile on her face. Y/n really was beautiful. Keep thinking shit like that and you're as good as dead, you scolded yourself. While Bobby does love you like a son that didn't mean he wouldn't kill you for being a bastard.

"Beginners luck," you said pretending to be bitter that you couldn't do the same the first time. She rolled her y/e/c eyes and you tried to hide a smile.

"Ok, we can talk right here," Tobias said coming back outside. He gestured to the chairs he had on the porch and sat down on one of them. The three of you quickly followed suit and you saw Sam bring out his notebook and pen.

"Alright, now if you could start from the beginning, perhaps there was something we missed," Y/n said gently getting straight to business.

"Well, it was supposed to be a family camping trip to celebrate my younger sister, Penny's 16th birthday," Tobias began after a shaky breath. "Me and Penny were sitting in my tent to get away from all the bugs, playing some card games," he paused.

"That was when we heard our Aunt Nancy scream, we looked outside of the tent and saw Grandpa Pat and Uncle Clyde load their guns," he continued. "By that point me and Penny were both scared out of our minds so we closed the tent and I got my gun ready. We heard some gun shots, it had to have been hit at least 5 times, and there was this horrible scream once after it got hit. Whatever made that noise wasn't human, I'm not even sure it was real. It was like nothing I've ever heard before. Everyone was outside, it got them all," Tobias started to stare at the ground, seemingly lost in the horrific memory while tears formed in his eyes.

"P-Penny just wanted to help. I tried to stop her but s-she took my gun and went out there.." he paused choking back tears. "but she n-never came back. The screaming lasted forever but then I heard something being dragged, like whatever it was was taking the..them someplace," he concluded.

"I see," Sam said sympathetically, "and do you know how you survived the attack?"

"No, there's no reason I can think of that can explain how I survived. I should be dead," Tobias responded.

"Do you have any idea of what it was that attacked?" You asked this time.

"The cops told me it was a bear, but I don't think so; whatever it was, it shouldn't be on this earth," Tobias answered.