Two Is Better Than One (Puyo Puyo Tetris)

A/N: Two Is Better Than One was a commission originally written back in April of 2021. Posting it up here and now for people to enjoy!

Themes: Threesome, Twin Sex, Magic

-x-X-x-

""That's our win! Now you have to do whatever we say~""

They'd… they'd hustled him! Or rather, that wasn't quite right. Hustling usually required one to be lured into a false sense of security first, and admittedly, Hikaru had never gotten that. The young man had been at his favorite arcade, playing his favorite game, Puyo Puyo Tetris. The thing about Puyo Puyo Tetris was… it could be played competitively.

There was even another cabinet in the arcade on the opposite side of the one he liked to use. But nobody else ever played it, so he always played solo. Until today, when Hikaru had found himself drawn into a competition the likes of which he'd never seen before. Someone else had been playing the other cabinet and at first he hadn't even noticed. Then, they'd sent him a challenge.

He'd accepted it without hesitation, eager to prove himself the best Puyo Puyo Tetris player that this arcade had to offer. And then he'd gotten his ass kicked. That was when he'd met Jay and Elle, fraternal twins who had poked their heads around the machine in order to gloat. Needless to say, when the girls had sent him another challenge soon after, Hikaru had been unable to help himself and had agreed to it… foolishly.

They'd beaten him three times before suggesting that they spice things up on the fourth. Loser had to do anything the winners wanted for the rest of the day. And yes, Jay and Elle had been very specific about winnerS, making it clear what they thought his chances were. Honestly, Hikaru knew then just as he knew now that he should have just cut his losses then and there and not agreed to the bet.

But his masculine pride, having already taken a beating, couldn't stand to willingly back down. And so, he'd let them suck him into one final match for all the marbles. Needless to say, he'd lost again, and now here he was, being dragged into the back of the arcade by both girls as they chattered in sync, their twin speak on a whole other level.

""Arcade's boring, let's go somewhere more FUN!"

Hikaru can already feel his wallet hurting. At least, that's what he assumes is going to happen here. After all, what else would two girls want with a guy like him? He's not… necessarily a loser, or at least he doesn't think of himself as one, but his insistence on spending all of his free time in arcades certainly didn't win him many friends at school.

Especially when all the 'normal' nerds had moved away from such activities and were happily going home to be the NEETs they were always meant to be. Meanwhile, all of the others had their own afterschool activities, from sports to shopping and everything that normies did in between.

He was the odd one out, with his love of old-fashioned arcades, and Hikaru knew that, he knew he was weird… he just didn't care. Now though, now that he'd been swindled by these twins, he was pretty sure they were going to make him buy them all the sweets he could afford, or maybe use him as their piggy bank and pack mule as they had him shop with them for the rest of the day.

Resigning himself to a rather shitty afternoon as the twins' bottom bitch, Hikaru is quite surprised when instead, they drag him to a nearby love motel and order him to buy them a room in eerie synchrony. Luckily the hotel runs on one of those fancy modern automated check-in systems, so he doesn't have to deal with a real live person, just a kiosk.

Shortly thereafter, Hikaru finds himself staring at Jay and Elle as they stand in front of him, hands on their hips and grins on their faces. They share a look… and then grin even wider, in a manner that Hikaru can't help but feel is downright predatory.

""It's time for our Synchronized Attack!""

The next thing he knows, he's pushed back onto the bed, forced to sit down as the two girls all but attack his crotch. Their dexterous hands work open his pants in short order, and together they draw out his dick. Hikaru blushes at the sudden exposure, afraid that they're going to start insulting his genitals or even worse, taking out phones to take pictures.

Luckily, that doesn't happen. Instead, he finds himself being sexually assaulted by the twins, their hands working up and down his shaft as their tongues poke out of the sides of their mouths rather cutely in concentration.

… Wait, seriously? This is what they wanted to do with him for the day? It actually takes Hikaru a little longer to get hard because he's so surprised… but not too long. After all, there's no denying it. Jay and Elle are a pair of cuties. Jay, with her periwinkle-colored straight hair, and Elle with her light-lime curls. As well, the two girls are wearing matching uniforms that he doesn't recognize, Jay in dark blue and Elle in maroon-brown, with leggings that disappear up under cute skirts.

So yeah, they're both pretty fuckable, Hikaru would say… and they're currently kneeling before his cock, jacking it off with intense looks on their faces. Rather than competing, they seem to be working together. This much be their 'Synchronized Attack', right? Just as Hikaru is thinking that, his eyes bulge as Jay and Elle share a look and then show the TRUE breadth of their Synchronized attack. While continuing to jerk him off with their soft palms and lithe fingers, the twin girls descend down below his cock in unison, and each takes one of his balls in her mouth as they suckle at his gonads like a pair of soft candies.

"Ohhh fuuuuck…"

Unable to help himself, Hikaru reaches out and places his hands on their heads. One hand slides through straight periwinkle hair and the other through lime-green curls as the young man shudders in abject pleasure. His cock throbs and pulsates in their double grip, and his balls churn as they suck away at them. It's… it's more than he could ever imagine, and it's all happening so damn fast!

But if he thought they were done, well, he had another thing coming. Pulling back from his balls all of the sudden, the twins share another grin and then look up at him with a glint in both of their eyes.

""Double Mischief!""

Hikaru barely has time to register what they've just called out (another special technique name, seriously?!) when the twins suddenly replace their hands with their mouths, and their mouths with their hands. Tongues sticking out much differently this time, their proceed to give Hikaru a double blowjob that he only ever could have dreamed of, while at the same time suddenly fondling his balls in their hands.

Needless to say, Hikaru's eyes go crossed from the pleasure as they suck his cock together, practically kissing one another when their lips meet atop his glans. Unable to hold back any longer, the young man lets out a hoarse shout and begins to cum, his seed squirting out from betwixt Jay and Elle's mouths. The duo are quick to woof down his cum like a pair of truly hungry animals, sucking up his jizz and swallowing it as they lick him and each other clean in no time at all.

Swaying a little bit, Hikaru isn't sure what to expect next. Needless to say, Jay and Elle standing up… and then popping their uniforms open to reveal their small A-cup breasts isn't it. Just the sight of the twin girls exposing themselves in such a way has Hikaru getting hard all over again as they continue to grin like the cats who mutually caught the canary.

And sure, that makes him the canary… but in this case, he can't help but be a little happy being said canary.

""Symmetry Strike!""

Once again, they shout out their intentions with a flashy special move name. Hikaru would be facepalming, if he wasn't way too busy groaning as the two of them show him what 'Symmetry Strike' means a moment later by shoving their small tits together around his cock. Alone, neither of them have enough for a titfuck. They've got what effectively amounts to mosquito bites. Not quite washboard flat, but certainly not enough for real cleavage, or to wrap around a cock.

However, together, which is how they seem to do everything, the twins have enough titflesh to make a good valley between them. As they both moan and flush, likely from their sensitive little nipples rubbing against one another, Hikaru can only groan as well, their breasts, while small, working nicely against either side of his shaft. Really nicely at that, the soft entrapment leaving him throbbing hard again in no time thanks to their eager ministrations.

For a second, Hikaru wonders if the two girls intend to make him blow his load again like this… but before he can ask, they both pull back, panting heavily, their nipples rock hard as they stare at him with lust in their eyes. They don't say anything this time, at least not at first. All of the sudden, Hikaru is being jumped as the twins hop up onto the bed and all but tackle him down onto his back.

Blinking up at the ceiling of the hotel room, wondering just how THIS has become his life, Hikaru barely has time to think before skirts go flying alongside their leggings. His cock, sticking straight up in the air, is an obvious place to go, and one pair of hands encircle it as Jay moves over his schlong. Meanwhile, Elle grins down at him from overhead, her own glistening wet pussy lips nestled betwixt her legs and quite visible from his current vantage point.

""Twin Hijinks!""

And like that, they both drop down. Jay drops onto his cock, and Elle onto his face. He's half-expecting to take Jay's virginity, but apparently they aren't nearly as innocent as they might appear. And alright, so Hikaru probably should have been expecting that considering how much has happened so far. Twin girls who have specialized secret attack names for their sex moves and who go around hustling guys into fucking them at love hotels can't exactly be called innocent, now can they?

It was just easy to forget that they were the sexual aggressors here, and if anyone was in over his head, it was Hikaru. Still, he wasn't about to let himself be defeated as easily as they defeated him at Puyo Puyo Tetris. Lifting his hands up, Hikaru grabs hold of Elle's thighs as the curly haired girl begins to ride him, and he pushes his mouth up into her cunt even harder, driving his tongue deep inside of her wet slit.

At the same time, Jay is still struggling to impale herself on his cock. He's not even that big, but she's pretty small with a petite body size, and she's currently working herself down his shaft an inch at a time, her cute face scrunched up in concentration, her hands curled into fists in front of her. So Hikaru helps her out… by thrusting up into her from below with all of his might, his hips spasming upwards even as he eats out Elle at the same time.

Both girls yelp and squeak and even squeal under his sudden efforts, but if Hikaru thought he was going to power bottom the entire thing, he has another thing coming. Rather, all he does is take his own place in the following threesome, because Jay and Elle are not to be underestimated. The twins recover fast enough and are soon humping both his cock and face all the harder, moaning wantonly as they ride him regardless of which end of him they're each at.

Hikaru's cock is buried in Jay's snatch and not going anywhere, given how tight she is around him. She bounces up and down on his dick, riding him like she means to drain him dry… and heck, maybe she does. It crosses Hikaru's mind that maybe these two have bad intentions for him… but nah, it's probably fine. He's in way too deep to stop now.

Speaking of in too deep, his tongue is as far as he can get it into Elle, and that seems to be driving the curly-haired twin wild. She's definitely the least composed of all three of them at this point. While Jay is riding him, having taken back control, Elle is squealing in between moans in fits and spurts, gasping as she tries to ride him, only for his hold on her thighs and his wild tongue to just drive her absolutely crazy.

For the first time, one of the twins speaks by herself… but then to be fair, she's talking to the other one.

"J-Jay! Swap with me!"

"Wha-?! Elle!"

In a moment, the two have changed places, almost like they teleported. Hikaru blinks as he goes from fucking Jay and tonguing out Elle, to fucking Elle and tonguing out Jay in what feels like the span of a few seconds. But in the end, he can't be bothered to spare the time to try and figure out how the hell that happened. He's far too busy giving Jay what he was giving Elle.

As the curly-haired twin settles into a pace of bouncing up and down on his throbbing cock, moaning up a storm, Jay discovers just WHY Elle wanted to swap as Hikaru begins to go to town on her dripping wet quim as well. The straight-haired twin yelps and then squeals and then moans as Hikaru drives his tongue up inside of her, his thumb sliding over to her clit and giving it a good rub that makes her go crazy for him.

The two girls are tag teaming him, there's no doubt about it, and Hikaru likes to imagine if it was just one of them, he'd have them dead to rights… at Puyo Puyo Tetris too! But this is fine too, the three of them having some sexy fun together, his cock buried in one tight snatch while his tongue wiggles around in the other. Finally, as if set to the same exact clock, the twins go nuclear in the same exact moment, squealing as they cum for him.

In response, Hikaru can't help but creampie Elle, and yet even as Jay is pulling off of his face, it's like they're flickering between one another, and he can't say for certain that he isn't creampieing Jay while Elle is the one pulling away from his face. Sitting up, Hikaru can't help but feel a little weirded out by everything at this point… and yet, just as he's considering demanding answers, Jay and Elle prove they aren't done quite yet.

The twin girls are on their sides on the bed before him, one pair of hands clasped together between them and the others clasped around one of their ankles, each of them lifting a leg high into the air. The end result is that their puffy pussy lips are smashed together in an obvious offering that has Hikaru rock hard all over again in no time at all.

The fact that he's suddenly ready to go again after already cumming twice is also weird… but he can't help crawling forward, stroking his cock slowly as he approaches the twins for yet another round.

"Um… how does this work exactly?"

Even as he asks, he's pushing his cock forward, pressing it into the tight space created by their dripping wet snatches. Rather than answer him properly like NORMAL people would, Jay and Elle exchange one last wicked grin… and then throw him one last wild curveball.

""ULTIMATE ILLUSION!""

With a groan, Hikaru suddenly feels like he's enveloped in two pussies… literally. Blinking dumbly, looking down and unable to figure out what's happening, the young man nevertheless thrusts forward as he somehow… fucks them both at once? That's not possible, it can't be possible… and yet, it's what he's experiencing. Somehow his cock has been split between them… or, or he's grown a second cock?

None of it makes sense, but then Hikaru can admit that it stopped making sense a while ago. What matters is that it feels good, undeniably so, to drive in and out of both girls as the twins clutch at one another, moaning and holding on to each other for dear life, kissing heatedly as he fucks them. Watching a pair of cute twins makeout while he somehow fucks both of them at the same time? Yeah, needless to say, it's fucking trippy.

And yet, Hikaru gives it his all. His pride as a man won't allow anything less. After all, he'd lost. He'd been beaten at Puyo Puyo Tetris fair and square, and if this was what the two of them wanted to do with him for the rest of the day, then he would be damn sure that they got what they wanted. Never let it be said that he was without honor, never let it be said that Hikaru welshed on his bets!

Grunting, the confused but undeniably aroused young man fucks into both Jay and Elle at the same time, plowing them both absolutely crazy in the wake of their final special move. He manages to extra another orgasm from each of them, before finally driving into both of them one final time and delivering a double creampie that leaves him feeling undeniably drained.

Groaning hoarsely as they moan wantonly, his cocks pulsing inside of them, delivering the payload twice over… Hikaru pulls back after a moment and lets out a sigh, slumping back on his knees as he tries to recover from the exertion he just put his body through. This… all of this was crazy, right? These girls… something was strange about them. Something almost… magical.

Looking up at them to see their state at this point, it's to find Jay and Elle both grinning at him, one pair of hands still clasped together, while their other hands are now raised in peace signs as they wink in sync with his cream flowing out of their freshly fucked pussies.

""Two is better than one!""

And even as tired as he is, Hikaru can't help but smile back and chuckle. Because they're certainly right about that…

-x-X-x-

If you'd like to read more of my work not seen on this website, check out Hentai-Foundry.com and QuestionableQuesting.com where I have over a thousand stories! I'm known as 'Cambrian' on those websites.

If you'd like to contribute to funding my writing at all, check me out on P atreon.com/Cambrian

Thanks for reading!