It's Better This Way (High School DxD)

A/N: It's Better This Way was a commissioned one shot originally written back in May of 2021. Posting it up here and now for people to enjoy!

Themes: Genderbending, Threesome, Fucked Silly

-x-X-x-

"Buchou! I'm here for today's contract!"

As Issei Hyoudou comes bounding into the ORC's clubroom, it's to find Rias and Kiba talking in quiet voices. Upon his bombastic and enthusiastic entry, they both turn to him and fix him with a gaze that actually makes the big ole pervert fear for HIS chastity for once. Only for a moment though, even as he skids to a stop and blinks slightly.

"Uh… B-Buchou?"

Without saying a word to him, Kiba turns to Rias and shrugs.

"He's as good an option as any, don't you think Buchou?"

Rias… hesitates for a moment, placing one palm on her cheek as she hums to herself consideringly.

"Well… I suppose it couldn't hurt. Issei! Kiba here needs your help with a particular client today. He's received a repeat contract, but with a request for an additional devil to support him on his task. Do you think you're up to it?"

If he ever wanted to prove himself worthy of Buchou's Oppai, Issei couldn't afford to say no! Or at least, that's what was going through the young man's head as he practically leaped forward, both fists in the air.

"Of course, Buchou! Leave it all to me!"

Giggling behind her hand at his enthusiasm, Rias nods and Issei blinks as she steps away, while Kiba steps up to his side.

"Very well then, how can I say no when my servant is so eager to please? Issei, Kiba, please stand still."

Confused, but happy to obey his big-breasted Buchou, Issei stands still as Rias raises her hands and begins a magical chant. She's very clearly casting a spell on him and Kiba but given that the Knight isn't moving a muscle in distress, this is what's supposed to be happening. After all, Rias wouldn't ever hurt her! Issei knew she could trust her Buchou!"

Wait… her? She?

Blinking owlishly as the magic fades away, the spell finished doing its work, Issei Hyoudou looks down at herself… and comes to the abrupt realization that she's now a girl. Beside her, Kiba is the exact same. Where once stood two young men, there are now two young women. It feels surprisingly natural to Issei, who remembered being a guy… but at the same time, felt perfectly at home in a woman's body. It was like her memories of being a man were drained of their color, a grainy white and black that made them feel almost disconnected from her as a person.

More than that though, what Issei notices in no time at all while looking down at herself, is the pair of absolutely MASSIVE oppai she now has! Even bigger than Rias and Akeno, she's pretty sure! Without missing a beat, the now female pervert reaches up and grabs hold of her titties, gasping at the sensation, at the feel.

"Nnngh, soooo good~"

"My oh my. So quick to play with the goods, Issei. No… that's not quite right, is it? In this new form… let's call you Itsuko."

Blinking at her Buchou's voice, Itsuko looks up to see Rias smiling indulgently at her. Beside her, the female Kiba smiles and nods.

"Yes, that is appropriate. In this form, you may call me Yumi, Itsuko."

Itsuko… Yumi. Yeah… yeah! That made sense to her, they weren't their old selves anymore, they were girls now! Which meant they needed girlie names!

"Now, we're done with the first half but not the second half. Stand still again for me, and please stop touching your chest for a brief second, Itsuko."

It takes all of her willpower to follow her Buchou's instructions. As soon as her hands are off her chest, Rias waves her own hands again and proceeds to transform their clothing as well. Itsuko doesn't mind it, not one bit. After all, her bagging male school uniform was actually kind of weird and not at all appropriate for her new female body!

Once it's over, the brunette checks out both herself and Yumi and can't help but be pleased with what she sees. Itsuko finds herself in a bunny girl outfit, a playboy costume that leaves her creamy thighs and her shoulders on display and also leaves most of her tits out, with only the nipple and a bit of the bottom cupped by the leotard-corset.

Yumi Kiba, meanwhile, has been transformed into a sexy naughty nurse, complete with a really short nurse uniform and lacy black stockings and a garter belt that disappears up under her skirt, giving a tantalizing offer of what lies underneath.

They look great, and Itsuko's hands are back on her tits as she moans happily, playing with her new fun bags. Rolling her eyes in fond exasperation, Rias sends her genderbent minions onto the client. Hopefully, he would appreciate this enough to continue his patronage of her and her peerage…

-x-X-x-

It hadn't really hit Itsuko, why they would need to be made into women in the first place. Truth be told, she's probably still a little in shock when they arrive at the client's house. She's certainly a little surprised to see the guy, who isn't too ugly looking, already has his dick out and in one of his hands, with his phone in the other ready to take pictures of the two of them.

"Shit, you both look amazing. And she's like you, yeah Yumi?"

"Of course, sir~ me and my Buchou would never try to cheat you. Until five minutes ago, Itsuko here was as masculine as you are… well, not QUITE as masculine, mm?"

Itsuko blushes as the client chuckles at that. His cock IS bigger than her male form's was, by quite a bit. But her memories of being a guy are still static-y and black and white and indistinct. Like they didn't really happen to her. So, she can't really bring herself to be all that offended on Issei's behalf. After all, he's not here right now, Itsuko is.

Of course, that's not where the surprises are done. The moment her fellow devil is done praising the client, Yumi drops to her knees and without missing a beat begins to suck him off. Finally, Itsuko begins to realize that there's more to all of this then being turned into a girl and playing dress up. She probably should have realized that earlier, but well… just because she was a woman now, didn't mean the brain meats she was working with upstairs were any better than they were when she was Issei.

"Y-Yumi?! What're you doing?"

Sucking down the client's cock for a long moment, making him toss his head back and groan in enjoyment, the sexy blonde nurse cosplayer pulls off of his dick with a pop a second later and gives Itsuko a raunchy grin.

"It's really silly. This client has a thing for fucking genderbent guys. Normal girls don't do it for him. He has to know that we were once boys before he can really get going. So, I come by on a regular basis after Rias transforms me to have sex with him. But today, our client wanted something more. He wanted a threesome! That's where you come in~"

"O-Oh…"

Itsuko finds herself staring at the guy's throbbing, manly cock as Yumi grins and suddenly stands up, walking over to her and taking her by the shoulders.

"You've got much bigger tits then me, Itsuko-chan. It only seems fair that you help out with those… assets of yours~"

Blushing up a storm, Itsuko doesn't know how to say no. No, truth is, deep down inside, she doesn't want to say no. She's as much a pervert as her male counterpart, and while oppai are still the best… the client's cock speaks to something newly awakened in the newly christened girl. As such, when Yumi pushes her down to her knees, Itsuko goes willingly, the genderbent girl coming face to face with her first dick.

"Here, I'll help you out~"

With Yumi's 'assistance', Itsuko is soon doing more than looking at her first dick. She's full out sucking her first dick. As the client groans, Itsuko bobs up and down his member, finding it surprisingly fun. Her eyes go crossed as she stares along his shaft, gauging how far she's getting with every back-and-forth motion. With Yumi helping her, she gets pretty far fast… but it's hard to get past the midway point. Her tight little virgin throat simply won't allow it.

"We'll have to work on your oral later, Itsuko. For now, the client's pleasure comes first. Which means… you'll have to use your breasts!"

Her breasts… yes, that was perfect! Without missing a beat, Itsuko pushes her massive gazongas up around the lower half of the man's shaft. The client lets out another groan at that, muttering something under his breath about how this was all so amazing, and he was the luckiest guy in the world. Itsuko doesn't really hear him, she's too busy having the time of her life.

It turns out, wrapping her sensitive tits around a rock-hard throbbing cock and sucking on the glans with her mouth… was great! It felt really good, and Itsuko couldn't get enough of it, truly! Her enthusiasm does not go unnoticed, not by Yumi OR the client. Yumi grins wickedly as she goads her fellow devil on, while the client… well, the client is only human. He can't hold it back forever.

"Fuck you sexy minxes are going to be the death of me! I… I… I'm cumming!"

It's not nearly enough warning, but that's okay because Itsuko is in no position to pull away anyways, not with Yumi pressed up against her back and pushing her forward. And so, in the end the genderbent bunny girl has to swallow every last drop… or try to, anyways. She definitely gives it a good attempt, but in the end the vast majority of the client's cum ends up drooling down her chin and painting her massive milk jugs white instead.

Still, she swallows what she can and finds the taste to be surprisingly good. Moaning up a storm, Itsuko leans back on her haunches, her hands molesting her new female body as she shudders in abject delight. She's… she's close to something. She's close to her first female orgasm, though she doesn't know it.

As she's working on that, as she's masturbating in front of both of them, neither the client nor Yumi are idle. With a lust-filled growl, the client grabs his naughty blonde nurse bitch and drags her over. Giggling, Yumi lets it happen despite having the strength of a Knight-class Devil, happily allowing him to bend her over and force her onto her hands and knees. Her nurse's skirt is flipped up and the lacy black lingerie Rias has transformed her underwear into are yanked down to her knees.

The client is inside of her a moment later, his hand thoughtlessly knocking her cute little nurse hat off of her head in his effort to grab a fistful of her blonde hair, yanking it back into a makeshift ponytail that he pulls and tugs on as he fucks her doggystyle. Yumi's cries at the rough treatment quickly reach Itsuko's ears… and watching her fellow genderbent devil get fucked from behind right in front of her turns out to be exactly what the doctor ordered.

Letting out a gurgling cry, the brunette reaches her first ever female orgasm right then and there. It's like a religious experience, her eyes nearly rolling back in her head but not quite as her teeth clench and she bucks her hips, squirting her pussy juices so hard that some even splatter across Yumi's face. Far from being upset with this, the blonde nurse actually licks her lips and gives Itsuko a grin, before of course her face contorts into more pleasured ecstasy as she cums around their client's cock again and again.

Just as she's coming down from her own climatic high, there's a loud masculine groan, and then a feminine squeal as the client thrusts deeper into Yumi then ever before and proceeds to creampie the blonde nurse cosplayer right there on the spot. As he pulls out of her and a satiated Yumi collapses forward onto her face with her pale behind high in the air, Itsuko's eyes zero in on the still hard, still twitching cock that just left her fellow devil's cunt.

Without hesitation, the brunette tosses herself across the room, using her devilish strength and agility to leap right onto the client's cock. He lets out a yelp of surprise at first as she pins him down, but then groans happily as she impales herself on his shaft, losing her virginity right then and there. But Itsuko doesn't care. All she cares about is getting to feel this big fat cock buried in her hungry little twat.

Of course, it gets even better when the client, realizing her massive titties are jiggling and bouncing right in his face, leans forward and begins to motorboat them. Itsuko moans, but what gets her engine REALLY revving is when he brings up his hands and grabs hold of her fun bags around the base, holding them steady so he can alternate between sucking on one and then the other, slurping away and biting and nibbling at her nipples.

That's when Itsuko's eyes finally do fully roll back in her head, the pleasure from her humungous oppai being so thoroughly played with driving her right over the edge and then some. She cums again and again around the client's cock, unaware that the magic Rias had used to turn her and Yumi into women didn't just alter their genders, it also increased their sensitivity by tenfold.

Obviously, this drives Itsuko absolutely wild, and she's soon cumming her brains out just like Yumi just got doing. Explosively orgasming again and again as a girl, compared to having to deal with a refractory period and empty balls as a guy… there's no doubt in the pervert's mind what's better. All of this pleasure, all of this ecstasy… she never wants it to end.

From the very beginning, she's ahegaoing, her eyes rolling around in her skull, her tongue lolling out of her mouth. Looking like the fucked silly slut she's always been deep down inside, Itsuko Hyoudou doesn't stop cumming for even a second, and finally her spasming pussy gets her creampied too. The client fills her with his seed… and Itsuko doesn't even CARE. She doesn't care that she might get pregnant, that she might get knocked up.

… To be fair, it's much harder for devils to get pregnant then humans. The chances of this mortal man managing to breed her and Yumi… why, it's one in a million, easily. But there always is the chance… and Itsuko doesn't give a shit. She welcomes it and all of this pleasure with open arms.

Of course, then Yumi interposes herself again, and the two girls find themselves having to share the client between them as their devilish stamina allows them to give the man the time of his life. Two insatiable, horny, absolutely drop-dead gorgeous girls are all his… and to his credit, the client makes very good use of both of them.

He might just be a human, but by the end even Itsuko is impressed with how many times he manages to get it up. He's so much more impressive than she was as a guy. His cock is bigger, his stamina greater… of course, Issei had never even had sex before, so probably it was a bad comparison… except Itsuko couldn't help it. The entire time, she was experiencing pure nirvana and overwhelming bliss as a woman. In the end, she simply couldn't stop herself from comparing her experiences and the man that Yumi had dragged her here to get fucked by, to her male self.

By the end of it all, after several more ours of intense three-way sex, in which Itsuko learned a lot about herself as well as pleasuring both men and women, the brunette had come to a conclusion. She'd come… to a decision.

Their costumes are in tatters, by the time they're finished. Both Itsuko and Yumi are dressed in cum-stained outfits, torn in some places, ripped in others. Their tits are out, their pussies are leaking the client's cum. They both do one more pose for him as he happily takes a picture for his 'private collection'. As Yumi explains it, it doesn't really matter if he posts photos of them both online… these aren't their 'real' forms anyways, after all.

Itsuko stays quiet about her true feelings regarding that, at least until they teleport back into the clubroom where Rias takes one look at the two of them and lets out a low whistle while grinning perversely. Because at the end of the day, their Buchou is a bit of a pervert herself.

"My oh my… he did quite the number on the two of you today, didn't he? You were right, Yumi, he was much more energetic with two women instead of one, it would seem."

"Yes Buchou. He really did his best to wear us out. Not that he succeeded, us being devils and all… but he gave it his all~"

Giggling, Rias raises her hands to begin the spell that will obviously turn them back… only to stop as Itsuko calls out.

"W-Wait, Buchou!"

Blinking, Rias cocks her head to the side and waits.

"U-Um… that is… could you not change me back? It's just… I've come to the conclusion that I like being a girl more than I ever liked being a guy. If it's possible… could we make this permanent?"

Rias' eyes widen at that.

"Are you sure, Issei?"

Smiling sadly, Itsuko shakes her head.

"I'm not Issei. Issei was a loser… I much prefer to be Itsuko."

Before Rias can give her reply, Yumi speaks up off to the side.

"Actually… if that is an option, I wouldn't mind that either. It's just… I've always felt more at home as Yumi then as Yuuto. I just never thought to ask before…"

Sharing a look of surprised solidarity, the two genderbent girls find themselves clasping hands in solidarity, their fingers intertwining together as they look back to their Buchou, their eyes filled with hope. Rias Gremory blinks at the two of them, staring in abject shock for a moment as she sees her plan to use Issei's perversion to try and get out of her engagement to Riser go up in smoke right before her eyes.

Because at the end of the day, the red head couldn't bare to say no to her cute little servants. With a soft, affectionate smile and a hand on her cheek, Rias Gremory lets out a small chuckle and a sigh.

"Very well, you two. If that's what you want."

Itsuko and Yumi share a wide smile and a nod, thanking their Buchou profusely and assuring her that it's BOTH what they want. All the while, the numerous creampies filling both of their unprotected wombs continue to leak out of their pussy lips ever so slowly…

-x-X-x-

If you'd like to read more of my work not seen on this website, check out Hentai-Foundry.com and QuestionableQuesting.com where I have over a thousand stories! I'm known as 'Cambrian' on those websites.

If you'd like to contribute to funding my writing at all, check me out on P atreon.com/Cambrian

Thanks for reading!