[Ellie's P.O.V]
Carlyle fell silent, and it was unclear whether he agreed or not. If he agreed, it would indicate a trace of conscience, but given the situation, it seemed he might not be able to fulfill the promise even if he wanted to.
Although I didn't know when Matthew's son had been taken, the chaos at the Stowe Pack's border had been ongoing for several months, so it was possible it had happened during that time. What he had experienced during these long months remained uncertain.
"I'm sorry," Carlyle said gently, his tone full of remorse.
"Carlyle... why did you become an accomplice to this cruelty? Give me back my son!" Matthew cried in sorrow, stumbling over something and groaning in pain. He then accused Carlyle, "Your family has been loyal for generations. How did you become a force for evil under your rule?"