Reassuring Colleen

As the lunch period started, I had barely left my classroom when Val approached me. "Hey," she said, hand going to mine and squeezing it tightly. She leaned in and gave me a quick peck on the forehead. "Want to grab some lunch together? I'll even handfeed you," she added, with a playful wink.

I glanced around - normally, Colleen would be the one to eat lunch with me after classes, but I didn't see her anywhere nearby. "Sure," I agreed. The thought came to mind, as we walked towards the cafeteria, that Val would also be a good person for testing out lines to reassure Colleen that Julia wasn't going to be an obstacle to our relationship. "There is something I need to talk to you about anyway."

"Oh?" She asked, tilting her head curiously to meet my eyes, half backwards-walking as she went. "I wonder what it could be?" She pushed her tongue against her cheek. "Is it that you're having sex with other girls? Because I already knew that, don't worry," she said, giving me a playful punch to the shoulder with her free hand.

"It's kind of that," I told her. "I'd rather sit down before saying it."

"Gotcha. Serious stuff," she said, straightening up and smoothing out her features - then breaking into a smile anyway. Her hand squeezed mine reassuringly, then she slipped her fingers together with mine, and she sort of leaned into me; with our relative heights, it created the vague impression she was about to collapse on top of me, but the closeness was still nice.

Once we had actually gotten our meals - for a moment, as we'd been going through line, I had thought I'd seen Colleen in the mess of the crowd, but then I'd lost her and been unable to find her again, so I had to assume she was just busy this period - I sat down with Val, just the two of us, in a table in the corner. She shifted her shoulders like she was hunching in for a fight, though her hands were opening her utensils. "Hit me, Sammy boy," she said.

"I Recognized someone." She blinked at that. "It doesn't mean I love you any less, but, I do love her more. You still have a guaranteed spot, and I still want you to be my girlfriend. You can meet her any time, she's in her Pokeball right now," I said, reaching down to idly brush the thing on my waistband.

"Your Recognized girl is on your Pokeball?" I couldn't blame her for jumping to that particular thing - it was probably fairly unusual for somebody to be willing to stick their soulmate in a confined empty space they couldn't escape for long periods of time.

"Hers is special," I said, pulling the ball out and placing it on the table. Val blinked at the sight of it, since it did look unusual - black with red stripes like blood running down it. "She can see out of it, and she can open it from the inside at any time."

"Oh, cool," Val said. She gave an awkward wave to the ball. "Hi, uh..."

"Bitch. She prefers Bitch," I told Val, which just made her brow crinkle still further. "I think you'd get along great, but I think she'd get along with basically everybody great."

Val let out a laugh, glancing down at the Pokeball. "I can imagine... sorry, man. Don't think I'm ready to meet the girl who cucked me just yet. Gotta mentally prepare. She's gonna have humongous tits, cocksucking lips, maybe be one of those slime types you can just stick it in everywhere..." there was a certain playfulness as she kept listing out traits that might be appealing to a guy, most of which were definitely appealing, though few of which described Julia.

I was just glad to see that she wasn't running away or doubting my claims of still caring about her, or anything like that.

* * *

I used Julia's house a lot. Firstly, because almost all of Julia's stuff was there (some of it was in the Pokeball with her), and secondly, because it was a private spot to just enjoy getting my dick sucked by whichever girl I'd selected that day. I didn't have to worry about my mom interrupting a blowjob to try to make me do some chore I'd forgotten. The privacy was nice. Like it was just me, and whichever girl I'd brought over.

That's why I only realized how awkward it would be to invite Colleen to Julia's house after Colleen showed up, looking flustered and unsure and wearing an insanely sexy top with just the right kind of underboob to really get me going, those new half-moon glasses she wore looking incredibly stylish. Her whole posture was afraid, like she was worried that I was about to abandon her. I kissed her on the lips, hoping it wouldn't make what I was about to say seem insincere (I'd just said it to Val), and pulled her inside with me, eventually sitting her down at Julia's table.

Julia was still in her Pokeball on my waist, and I swallowed. It was Colleen that spoke up first. "I-I've been researching, and, so Recognition, the theory is, that it happens because, because your souls are perfect for one another, a-and, so, it's possible, there's not- they don't think it's like- it's not like there's one fit, they don't think that's how it works, since then, there's millions of people in the world, and j-just insane amounts of possible people to exist, but only a few of them do, s-so, if you could only Recognize one person, it'd be less likely than somebody invisibly marking a grain of sand, and then you picking that out of all the beaches in the world at random, when you only visit the beach once in your whole life. S-so, but, it's still pretty unlikely to Recognize somebody, given it happens rarely, but there's not... I mean, there's not technically any reason that it couldn't happen, and it's a... I mean, you meet maybe tens of thousands of people in your lifetime, and there are just... the, um, the ratio of people, since Pokegirls came around, to the number of people who Recognized a Pokegirl, is smaller than the ratio of people who Recognized a Pokegirl, to one. S-so, we could still Recognize each other, if I do threshhold, even if you recognized Julia already," she said, finally finishing her thought.

"Okay," I told her. Val definitely hadn't responded this way, so I had no idea what to say. I reached over for Colleen's hand, squeezing it in mine. "The fact that I Recognized someone else doesn't mean I l-" I couldn't bring myself to say that word, even now, stupid as it was, "like you any less," I told her. "I do like her more, and, if I do Recognize you, I'm sure I'll like you just as much. But whatever the case, you still have a guaranteed spot, and I still want you to be my girlfriend."

She smiled at that, so much tension leaving her body as she nodded meekly in response to that statement.

"She's in her Pokeball right now, would you like to meet her? I think you'd get along great." Colleen was really gregarious and friendly with other girls, normally.

Colleen swallowed, then nodded. "I-if I'm going to be your P-Pet, then I have to meet her eventually," she said.

I took the Pokeball off of my waistband, and before I could even open it myself, there was Julia, wearing a "goth catgirl" cosplay (black cat ears, black tail, short frilly skirt and frilly black tank top with a skull on it) and immediately glomping onto Colleen, making her squeak in surprise as Julia just hugged her tightly against herself. They looked nice together, Julia's dark skin tone contrasting lewdly with Colleen's paler shade as she rubbed her cheek up against Colleen's.

"Nyaaa, don't worry, Colleen, I'm just a bitch onahole, I hope you and goshujinsama get married and have lots of cute babies I help raise. I'd never ever do anything to get between you and goshujinsama, you're too cute together."

Colleen was unusually anxious, for dealing with another girl, and just gave Julia a nervous pat on the back. "I th-thought you were, a GhostRider?"

"I'm just playing at being a kitty cat, Colleen," Julia explained, though she kept herself held tight against Colleen, not quite rubbing her cheek against the other girl's face, but definitely being incredibly close. "Catgirls are a huge fetish for guys, nyaa. So I dress up like one for Sam, nyaa, and meow and purr and rub and lick like his cute little kitty cat."

My cock was pretty much rock hard watching the two close up like that, especially because Colleen seemed to be rapidly becoming more reassured that Julia wasn't a threat to our relationship, she actively wanted to help us both stay together. Her eyes turned to me, big behind her glasses. "Do you w-want me to dress up like a catgirl too, Sam?"

"Ooo! I have extra costumes, you could totally wear one and meow like a good kitty for Sam, I bet he'd love that, right, goshujinsama?"

"You don't have to," I told Colleen. Julia loved her cosplay, but that didn't mean Colleen did.

"I-if you'd like it, then I want to," she said.

I couldn't deny the idea held appeal to me. "Sure. Go ahead."

"Come on, Colleen," Julia said, dragging the other girl behind her. Strangely, Colleen still seemed nervous and anxious around her, even as she receded from me - normally she was way better with other girls.

I just chalked it up to her general anxiety about the whole situation with me now having a soulmate, and her worries that she'd given me her virginity and agreed to have my child for nothing. She definitely hadn't, obviously, but she couldn't know that for sure. She didn't know Julia like I did; if Julia had been some parity nut like Andrea, I probably would have had to break things off with Colleen. I couldn't have beared to hurt or bully Julia like I did Rachel or Andrea, where part of the fun was making them annoyed at me. I could bully the fuck out of her, but that was because I knew that Julia liked it when I stepped on her face, went from another girl's ass to her mouth, choked her, slapped her, spanked her, used her as a footstool, called her names...

My dick was way too hard. I got up from the table, walked over to the couch, and took off my pants to free it up to the open air, letting out a sigh of relief as it did so, settling down on the couch. About the same time I had settled into place, Julia and Colleen emerged from Julia's bedroom, with Colleen wearing some cute, fluffy brown cat ears on a headband. With Julia's hands on the other girl's shoulders, pushing her forward, urging her to be confident, my cock twitched in the air.

"Nyaa! I'm your sex kitten Bitch, and this is your sex kitten Collie!"

"M-meow," Colleen said, flushing red the moment the word had left her lips.

"Why are my sex kittens named after dogs?" I asked Julia, smiling as she and Colleen both moved to kneel between my legs.

"Nyaa, because you're really bad at naming cats, goshujinsama," Julia replied with a bright smile. She let Colleen take the first round sucking my cock, and Colleen looked up at me, her cheeks red, but leaned forward to take me into her mouth despite her embarrassment. "Don't worry, Collie, goshujinsama really likes you, just go ahead and suck his cock like a good girl."

Colleen swallowed and then took me into her mouth. It was a slow, languid movement as she slid down my length, her eyes staring up at me all the while. There was still that nervous tension, like she was worried she'd displease me, but I reached down to softly brush my fingers through her hair. I kind of wished her cat ears were real, so I could scritch them, but if she threshholded, she might actually get some kind of neat different ear like that - or she could just wind up like Julia and look pretty much the same as she did as a human.

Colleen hit the base of my cock, and I groaned, leaning back on the couch as I just relished the feeling of her throat around my cock. Her tongue was going wild inside her mouth, lashing and licking hungrily and as I leaned back, Julia swooped in, slithering into the space between my thigh and Colleen's mouth to start sucking on my balls, staring up at me warmly, fiercely, but with eyes that said it would be completely fine if I paid her no mind and just focused on Colleen. No, more than that, she actively wanted me to pay all my attention to Colleen no matter what she did, both to make Colleen feel secure, and to give Julia some denial/contempt play.

I did exactly as directed, turning my attention entirely to Colleen. My hand softly stroked her cheek, admiring her features, her cute half-moon glasses, the way that, leaned forward on my dick like this, her butt was put on full display. She had a nice ass, and I admired it as I looked down at her, continuing to softly touch her, petting her hair, playing with her braids, brushing along her cheeks and everything else.

She slid back suddenly, until my cock left her throat, at which point she took in desperate gasps around my dick, hot breaths tickling my whole length. She didn't peel all the way back, though, keeping my dick still in her mouth, resting on her active, vigorous tongue, which licked and slapped at it as she recovered. Her eyes stared up at me, warm, needy.

Julia popped off my balls for just a moment. "Nyaaaa! I think you should say something to Collie, goshujinsama, she's being a good kitty for you and sucking your cock," she said, reminding me that Colleen definitely deserved verbal praise, before slurping my balls into her mouth.

"You're doing amazing, Collie," I said, that ridiculous nickname earning a scarlet flush from Colleen as I gave it to her. She sucked my cock back into her throat, making me groan. "Fuck, that's good. You're so good at this, Collie. I love-" I had brainlessly started to say that, but my experiences with Val told me I needed to control myself, "-it. I love your cocksucking skills, you're so dedicated, so eager," I explained, and she nervously smiled with her eyes up at me, slurping on my cock as she held herself down in my pelvis, Julia just rubbing cheeks with Colleen in an intensely sexy way as she continued to suck my balls.

Both girls held that position, Julia sucking my balls, Colleen deepthroating my cock, and it just seemed to go on and on as I offered soft praises for Colleen. As I just relished the sensation of a wet mouth around my dick, Julia surprised me by being the first to come, moaning into my pelvis as she twitched frantically in place, her hips bucking at the air, her eyes rolling up in pleasure.

It was then that I realized Colleen wasn't playing with herself at all, during the blowjob. "Play with yourself, Collie," I ordered her, and her hands immediately went to work, one slippingu p through the underboob window on her top, the other sliding down into her panties with practiced ease. "Whenever you're sucking my cock, you can - and should - play with yourself, if I haven't told you not to. That goes for any roleplaying scenario." I wanted her to enjoy herself too. She just nodded around my dick as she blew me.

Her fingers were manic in their labors, as if making up for lost time, and I couldn't help but notice that she was doing that same thing again, where she choked herself on my cock because she was too distracted by her own pleasure. I shifted my hands, grabbing her braids in either hand, and forcibly peeled her back so that she could properly breathe around my dick. Julia shifted up as well, kissing and pecking at the newly-exposed area of my dick as Colleen gasped for breath around my length. While Julia was utterly focused on her work, eyes on my dick, Colleen looked up at me with genuine concern that she might have offended me somehow.

"I just want you to breathe," I told Colleen. "I love your throat, but I don't want you to pass out because you're too lost in pleasure." She nodded quietly around my dick, looking vaguely guilty.

"Nyaa!" Julia offered, giving Colleen's cheek a quick, affectionate peck. "Don't worry, goshujinsama just wants you to be happy while you suck his big, hard, throbbing cock, as you take it in and out of your throat, nyaa! There's nothing to worry about, nyaa!" Colleen blushed at Julia's statement, and gently pressed against my grip on her hair - I let her move down, keeping a hold of her braids just in case she lost track of how long she was down there.

Julia didn't go down to my balls, instead watching with a happy smile as Colleen bobbed up and down my cock. Colleen's hand on her tit went wild, her breast rising and falling and turning and twisting as her fingers just went at it, while the hand in between her legs rubbed and frigged at a pace that might have been a furious pounding, if it had been my cock. She moaned, occasionally, around my dick, this beautiful wet noise that made me groan in pleasure, tilting my head back and just digging my hands into the couch beneath me.

The whole time, Julia's brilliant blue eyes stared at Colleen's lips, flicking up to her face occasionally, just watching the other girl. It wasn't jealousy, or desire on her features, but a simple, pure-hearted joy, happy that me and Colleen were both enjoying ourselves.

As Colleen started to increase the intensity of her noises, moaning more frequently, loudly, vibrating on my cock as her eyelashes fluttered, Julia suddenly swooped in, pressing her nose up against my balls and finding her way to my ass, starting to frantically press her tongue in. I grunted, gasping at the attention, while Colleen kept bobbing with an ecstasy-rattled intensity, until at last she came, moaning on my cock - and a moment later, with a bit of help from Julia, I came too, groaning as I simply unloaded inside of Colleen's mouth.

Once I started coming, Julia pulled back, grasping my dick in one hand and frantically jerking it off in Colleen's mouth. "Give your kitty her cream, goshujinsama! Look how much she loves it, she's coming from the taste, nyaa! Good kitties get lots and lots of cream, nyaaa!" Fuck. Stupid as her roleplaying was, it was hot as hell, so I came and came inside of Colleen's mouth, until that orgasm finally subsided, and Colleen remained there, quietly slurping on the tip of my cock as I cought my breath. She hadn't swallowed, meaning my cum was in her mouth still.

An idle thought came to mind. "Collie, I think Bitch wants some cream too," I told her, and Julia nodded rapidly, stretching her tongue out invitingly. "Don't kiss her," I noted, as Colleen popped off my cock. "Just drool it all over her face. Mark her with my cum and your spit."

Colleen blushed at that command, but she nodded, quickly positioning herself above Julia, who simply closed her eyes and basked as my cum and Colleen's spit rained down on her face. Some of it splattered into her mouth or landed on her tongue, but most of it hit pretty much everywhere else, marking her gorgeous dark skin with streams of milky white as she sat there, taking it all without complaint.

The show was too much for me. I wanted Colleen, now. "Bitch, should I fuck Collie on your bed or your mom's?" The unused, emptied-out bedroom had been her mother's, it turned out.

"Whisheffer," Julia slurred out around the cum that was in her mouth, her tongue quickly exiting her mouth to try to lick up semen from wherever she could get it.

I thought about it for a second, and decided on her mom's - Julia's bedroom was a bit of a mess, with her owning way too much random junk that was just left lying around. Her mother's was pretty much clean. "Come on, Collie," I told Colleen, placing one hand on her butt and just groping away as I drew her with me to the bedroom. Julia actually started to crawl after us, and I chose to ignore her, knowing it's what she'd want.

Once we were in the bedroom, I laid Colleen out, quickly stripping her of her clothes, but not the cute cat ears. I liked them, though not for the "catgirls are cute" reason that Julia probably was thinking. I liked them because they let me imagine that Colleen really had threshholded, that she was my Pet, and that she was mine and mine alone. It was a fantasy I wanted to be true, to have that reassurance that Colleen would never leave me. "Collie, you're such a cute kitty," I told her, idly scratching her chin as I got in between her bare legs, her naked sex now presented to me. "I want to give you lots of litters of kittens, do you want that too?"

"Meow, yes, Sam," she said, then flushed. "S-sorry, should I have said Ma-ahn!" She was cut off as I thrust inside her, filling her up in a single, sharp stroke. My hands grasped her by the thighs, tilting her legs backwards and beginning to just rut inside her, pounding away frantically, my balls slapping at her cute ass.

"Sam is always good for you, Collie," I told Colleen. "You never have to call me anything else. Even once you're my Pet, you won't have to," I continued, pounding away, just thrusting away at her wonderfully tight and wet sex. It took hardly any time at all for Colleen to come, her pussy squeezing hard on my dick, and I groaned at the feeling, relishing it for a long few seconds, before I started to thump inside her spasming sex. "You're my Pet right now," I told her. "We can pretend we Recognized each other, too," I told her, knowing that she'd liked that fantasy earlier. "I know what it's like, so I can roleplay even better than before," I explained, leaning down over her to run my tongue along her neck. She shivered at the touch.

"Wha, what's it like?" She panted out, still recovering from her orgasm.

"It's easy," I told her. "Everything's easy. Nothing the other person does annoys you, even the annoying things," I told her, giving her cheek little pecks as I spoke. "You don't have to worry that they don't actually like you, that they're just pretending because they need you. You don't have to worry that they're taking advantage of you, taking and taking but never giving. You don't have to worry about any of that, because you know they love you, bone deep, that they'd never hurt you, and you don't have to worry that that's too much love, that you can't pay it back in kind, because you have exactly that much for them right back."

She mewled softly at those words, twisting between me as she started to come on my cock all over again, her legs straining against my grasp for a moment before I let them go, letting them snap around my waist as she held and ground me deep inside her.

"A-and," Colleen panted, still in the throes of orgasm, "y-you don't have to worry, that they'll l-leave you, r-right?" She panted out, twitching and writhing beneath me.

"Right," I told her, then kissed her firmly on the lips, my tongue forcefully invading her mouth, twisting and twining around, teasing her own tongue as she jerked and twitched beneath me. I heard more than saw, as Julia entered the bedroom, crawling over to the bedside; a glance her way showed that her face was still coated in my cum, her eyes still closed as a consequence, and I twitched inside Colleen, intensifying my pace inside her in response to my hot-as-hell soulmate just kneeling by the bedside, cum on her face, still wearing that goofy goth catgirl cosplay.

"Nyaa, goshujinsama's cream is so tasty, can this lowly bitch onahole of a kitty-cat lick it alllll up?" She asked me, and I just grunted acknowledgement, one hand quickly giving her a thumbs up before my hands sought out Colleen's own, lacing my fingers together with hers as I pumped away. She was so hot, so eager, her legs squeezing me against her whether or not she was currently coming, her whole body twitching with seemingly every thrust on my part, as if she was about to come just from that alone.

In the periphery of my vision, I watched as Julia slowly slipped the cum right off her face, then fed it into her mouth, slurping it off each finger with eager pride. It just encouraged me to go at Colleen faster and harder, pumping away, making her squeak in pleasure as I took her, as I enjoyed her sexy body beneath me.

A couple orgasms on Colleen's part and a few minutes later, Julia started to crawl up onto the bed, just watching the scene as I fucked away at Colleen's pussy. Her eyes looked dotingly down at the scene of the two of us, and I felt as she gently reached down for Colleen's belly, the back of her hand brushing against my stomach. "This womb has goshujinsama's first baby in it... I'm so happy for you, Colleen. Nya," she added, almost absentmindedly. "I promise to give it lots of love and help you raise it, don't worry, Colleen," she said. She actually sandwiched her head between Colleen and I's stomachs, purely te press her ear against Colleen's, like she could hear the baby at this early stage.

That simple act of intimacy, unfeigned to the point that she had completely forgotten her character, pushed me over the edge, and I exploded inside of Colleen. She gasped at the feeling of my cum, her tongue starting to become more energetic in my mouth, as if to coax that little bit of extra sperm out of me that way. When I was completely spent, I pulled out of her, rolling over to one side; Julia kept her cheek pressed against Colleen's stomach, eyes closed, and my cock twitched at the show.

Colleen panted softly, her skin a bit slick with sweat, and eventually, she drew up one hand, gently petting Julia where she rested. "Nyaa, thank you for petting this kitty," Julia proudly and unabashedly declared. I just leaned into Colleen and gave her a kiss on the cheek, cuddling with her for a time.

Once that time was done, though, we went back to fucking like rabbits. Julia kept gushing over the both of us in a way that seemed to be helping coax Colleen out of all the anxieties she had started to feel, born of me having Recognized somebody else.

By the end of the day, both me and Colleen slick with sweat and half-conscious on the bed together, my cum leaking out of her pussy... well, I think that I had successfully reassured Colleen that I still wanted her, even though I couldn't quite manage to bring myself to say the l-word for fear of rejection.