Max gestured toward his paper. "Let's break it down. The flowerpot was deliberately placed there long ago, not by the cleaning lady or the boyfriend, but by an entirely unrelated person—the night security guard. He's out of the picture, bedridden and helpless, but his actions set the stage for everything that followed.
The cleaning lady opening the window? She was an unwitting participant, her action timed perfectly with the boyfriend and Miss A arriving at the exact spot beneath the flowerpot. And here's the kicker: even if someone were to suspect the boyfriend, there's no direct evidence tying him to the falling flowerpot. He didn't touch it, didn't move it, and had no control over the window being opened. Every piece of the puzzle looks random."