The man furrowed his brows and looked at her puzzled, wondering if he heard her wrong.
Seeing his confused expression, she realised she needed to properly explain herself. "I mean… If you want to, I can-"
"Listen, kid," He cut her off and spoke in a calm manner. "What happened today was a mistake and I'm sorry about that. I don't think we should get any more involved with each other."
"N-No... I just w-want to-"
"No, you don't." he cut her off again and spoke in a much more stern and cold tone. "Believe me. You don't want to get involved with me. I enjoy pain, and I enjoy inflicting it even more. And you are not built to endure it. You fainted twice just in this short while, what makes you think you can handle me?"
"Don't be blinded by the soft kisses and sweet gestures." He continued. "That's just a very small part of me. There's a monster inside me that thrives on suffering and I cannot guarantee that you will be spared so easily every time."
She was stunned into silence as she remembered the terrible pain she had endured in the last couple hours. The burning sensation in her ass was yet to fully subside, and the mind-numbing pain she felt as his huge cock dislocated her jaw still made her body tremble.
When he saw the fear and hesitation swirling in her eyes, he huffed and grabbed her by the elbow before dragging her towards the door.
"W-wait, I-" she tried to argue but he didn't let her continue and spoke over her.
"Enough, don't test my patience." He opened the door and threw her out as he said. "Just go home and go on with your life. And DO NOT come here again."
He threatened in a cold tone and slammed the door shut in her face, leaving her standing in the dark and narrow alley.
• - •
Rose stared at the closed door, her eyes glistening with unshed tears. She was sad and disappointed but didn't know what to do.
In the narrow back alley, a gust of wind swept past her, lifting her skirt up as it went by. She felt a cold chill in her crotch area and immediately pushed her skirt down as she realized she wasn't wearing anything under her skirt, and her panties were still in the bedroom somewhere.
The chill creeped up her spine and made her tremble as she looked back at the closed door with pitiful eyes. But she knew waiting there wasn't going to make a difference, so she clutched her shirt close with one hand and turned around.
With one last lingering glance at the closed door, she made her way out of the back alley while holding her skirt down with the other hand.
She stopped at the corner of the alley and looked around to figure out where exactly she was currently. And once she figured out her general location, she waited for the street to be empty before heading in the direction of her house.
It took Rose almost another half hour of sneaking around and avoiding other passerbys to finally reach her house.
But she stopped at the corner overlooking her house and glanced around carefully. And only when she was sure no one was around, did she rush towards her front door.
She then heaved a sigh when she found the door still locked. That meant she was the first one home, despite being three hours later than usual. But that wasn't surprising at all, as 'the witch' was always out late most of the nights.
It was just another carefree day for the witch, while Rose's life had changed completely in the span of couple hours. But then again, the witch probably wouldn't even care if Rose told her what she had been through today.
Rose shook her head to get rid of idle thoughts and quickly pulled out a key from her bag's side zipper. She then quickly unlocked the door and walked inside, closing the door behind her.
But what she didn't know was that, a pair of eyes were staring at her through the window of the neighboring house and took notice of her late arrival, as well as her unkempt appearance.
• - •
After he threw the girl out, Nic couldn't focus on his work anymore, so he walked back into the bedroom and sat down on the bed. The wet spots on the bedsheet caught his eye and he let out a snicker.
She was... interesting, he mused and then shook his head. Then he noticed something from the corner of his eye and he looked down to see a light pink underwear lying on the floor by the bedside.
Did she forget it? Or did she leave it behind purposely?
Nic picked it up and felt something slimy on his hand. He turned over the panties and saw a red-white substance dripping out of the underwear.
He remembered that earlier, when he pulled her underwear down to put the ice, blood and cum was still leaking from her ass. It must've pooled in the underwear on the way home from the park after their 'first round'.
The scene of his cum dribbling out of the girl's ass flashed in his mind and his dick throbbed with excitement again. He looked at the underwear in his hand thoughtfully and pulled his dick out before wrapping the underwear around it. He then closed his eyes and began to stroke it long and hard as he imagined ravaging her ass again.
But no matter how long he tried, he couldn't feel that thrill and excitement anymore. After a few more mundane minutes, he gave up and threw the underwear aside as he laid back on the bed, with his cock still out and standing tall.
"I'm slipping again." Nic mumbled out loud.
A conflicting emotion flickered across his eyes as the image of the girl's tear-stained face came into his mind. "Was I too harsh on her? May I should've-"
"No." he immediately cut his thoughts short and got off the bed before adjusting his pants and heading out of the room. "It is better for her to stay far away from me."
• - •
Rose stood under the shower with her clothes and turned it on. As the cold water hit her face, she closed her eyes and replayed everything that happened in the last few hours.
It all felt like a dream, but her aching body reminded her it was very much real. But despite the tremendous pain she endured, she began to feel giddy inside. She touched her swollen lips and remembered that gentle yet forceful; passionate yet punishing kiss that made her heart race a-mile-a-minute.
Her lips curved into a sweet smile as she slowly removed her wet clothes and quickly toweled off. She then changed into a top and shorts before laying down on her bed.
Drained and exhausted, she immediately fell into a deep slumber throughout the night.