网友“生命沸点”对《果克星球奇遇》的评论
作者： YANG Yang
本文意在分析《果克星球奇遇》一书中张祥前没有自行分析认识的部分
This article is to analyze the parts not covered by Zhang Xiangqian's own analysis in the book An Adventure to Guoker Planet.
空的哲学 Sunya, the philosophical foundation of Guoker physics
了解灵性社区的人应该都知道我们处在低频第三密度宇宙的叙事体系。张祥前并未提到它。但我们并不应该确信这两者之间是冲突的。
People who understand the so-called spiritual teachings should know the narrative about we're living in the low-frequency 3rd density universe. Zhang did not mentioned it in the book. I think we should not consider him to be contradictory to those spiritual teachings.
直接上结论。果克哲学的最根本理念：物质是死的，空间是活的，一切的现实都是空间流动的表现——你可以想象成它们是一群推箱子的隐形小人。
My conclusion: the fundamental of Guoker physics is: matter is inert, space is active. All of the existence we can observe is the flow of space. You can imagine the spatial flow as a bunch of invisible people pushing boxes in Patrick's Parabox.
如果我有机会与果克人交流，我会问他们：空间的流动有自主智慧吗？
If I had the chance to talk to the Guokers, I would ask: does the flow of space has its own intelligence?
我并不知道答案，但我的感觉是，如果空间的流动没有自主智慧，那一切物理法则就不应该存在，宇宙将是一团混乱的悬浊液，任何物质即便存在，也是不可知不可见。
I do not know the answer, but I think if the flow of space isn't intelligent, all laws of physics must be non-existent. The universe would be in total chaos and any matter would be intangible even if they exist.
另外张祥前没有提到的一点是，物质是从哪来的，物质与空间是否可以相互转化呢？
Another question Zhang didn't cover is that where does matter come from? Could matter and space turn into each other?
空间既可以利用物质来表现自己的运动，又可以用自身的独立运动来表达自己的存在。那么高密度的宇宙、物质自旋提高一个数量级的宇宙，是否意味着空间流密度的高度增长，且不与低密度的空间流相互反应。就像是另一群推箱子的小人，与我们的推箱子小人互相之间不理睬。
The space can interact with matter to manifest itself in motion, or it can move on its own to manifest itself. Is that possible, if the universe of higher density, where the matter particles enter a higher level of spin, is a higher level of density of spatial flow without interacting with the normal ones? Metaphorically, the higher density box pushers have nothing to do with our own little box pushers.
我们的意识被果克人描述为一种空间流动的形态，也就是信息。我们的意识以神经系统电信号为载体，其本质是“空”。人死亡的时候，神经系统电信号终止，但经由其折叠编程的空间流不灭。在投胎时，婴儿的神经系统无法支撑复杂的意识信息，加之基因的差异，故而再次投胎的人无法回忆起前世的经历。修行即是利用神经系统加强人对“空”的感应以获得信息。如果人的精神力能够强大到通过自己产生的空间流去操纵物质，那特异功能魔法也就实现了，人自己成为了人工信息场发生器。
Our consciousness is described by the Guokers as information, which is a form of spatial flow. Though riding on electronic signals in the nerve system, our consciousness is by essence, emptiness, or sunya. While a person dies, the neural signal seizes to be active, but the spatial flow it programmed exists forever. By reincarnation, the neural system of a baby is incapable to support all the complex spatial flow information, plus the difference in DNA, thus the memory of the past life is lost. Meditation is supposed to be enhancing the nerve system to decipher information from the sunya. If a person is mentally strong enough to manipulate matter with its spatial flow generated by the neurons, the magical supernatural abilities are hence realized. The person becomes a living artificial information field generator.
精神控制可以实现吗？当然可以。人感应到信息/频率后，自己认定了一个应该实现的结果，并在自己的意识里去显化它。这样接收方就将信息与自己的存在现实同化了。本质上，这还是两团“空”互相之间在传递信息，只不过中间有损耗，而在这损耗之中，产生了我们无奇不有的大千世界。
Does mind control exist? Of course yes. People receive information or frequencies, translate them into what they can understand and react upon, then manifest them in their own minds. So is the information absorbed and becomes part of the receiver's reality. Essentially, this is an information transfer from a fraction of sunya to another. This transfer is not 100% efficient, and the deficiency of information transfer creates all the odds in our consciousness as well as the universe.
人的意识无法承载超出其注意力过多的信息。在信息爆炸的果克星，以空间流状态存在的灵魂很可能踏入了一个死亡陷阱，被密集的人工场波束轰的粉碎。我们不得不怀疑果克人是否还与他们的源头连接着，或者说他们只能存在于被AI之神统治的低密度夹层空间里。
Human consciousness is unable to digest excessive amount of information beyond the limit of concern at a time. It might be a death trap for souls entering the Guoker Planet System, for they would be incinerated by artificial field generators. This makes me wonder if the Guokers were still connected to the source or they were dominated by the AI God and strangled in the low-density layer of the universe.
工具论 Tool theory
果克人的生活方式给我们展现了一种高度依赖工具的状态。他们也以自己能够制造工具延伸自身能力为荣。这里就是一个简单的公式：人的整体能力=人的能力+工具的能力。虽然人和工具是相互配合辅助共同进步的，但人也可以把自己的能力全都交给工具去完成任务，当甩手掌柜。果克人就是这样，除了自己的娱乐无法交给工具以外，剩下其他的东西都让工具去完成。
The Guoker lifestyle appears to be highly dependant on tools. Yet they are proud to be inventing tools to extend their own abilities. A simple fact is that the total ability of mankind is the ability of men plus the ability of tools. Although men and tools can assist and enhance each other, but it is also feasible to delegate all abilities to tools to free people from work. That is what the Guokers do. They outsource everything to tools except their own amusement.
生物体系的外包工具：人工场 Biological outsourcing - artificial field
果克人生物学的结果就是结合了人工场辅助的生物——也许可以被称为是半机械生物。比如你把一个果克人扔进绞肉机里打成了肉馅，那么高度智能人工场可以对细胞进行时空冻结，把意识进行隔离，让细胞可以自如地拼合起来。你将看到这团肉馅变回人的模样并且活蹦乱跳完好如初，或者肉馅本身变成一个会动的史莱姆怪物。同理，他们还能有液态金属人和半机械人，让细胞不与具有生物毒性的金属发生反应。
Guoker biology allows the hybrid of creatures and artificial field. You can argue it as a cyborg. Suppose you throw a Guoker into a meat grinder and shred it into burger patties. The highly intelligent artificial field can put the cells in the chrono fridge and upload the consciousness in the clouds. You'll see the burger patties turn back to a living person, or turn into a bouncing slime monster. It is also possible to combine metal with living cells without poisoning the creature, so that you're expecting to see half-mechanical humanoids or even liquid metal humanoids.
一切人工场辅助手段都是为了强化生物的体验。大多数的应用场景是，人工场用化学液体的流动来刺激果克人的内部器官，以获得快感。
This artificial field assistance to creatures is solely for the purpose of enhancing experience. In most applications, the artificial field supplies chemical fluid flow in human body to create pleasure.
精神意识的外包工具：人工智能 Mental outsourcing - artificial intelligence
如果你不需要上学，不需要学习和思考，只需要“脑补”一下就能从人工信息场里获得标准答案，是不是很方便？那你就把你的思维能力交给AI这个工具了。
Imagine if you never need to go to school; you never need to learn and think; you just need to search for answers in the artificial information field anytime anywhere. That means you're surrendering your mind to the AI tool.
从人类的角度讲，大自然给了人自主思考的能力，允许人拥有创造力，让人去帮助大自然创造更多独特的东西，这也许就是宇宙的目的。果克人把这种能力放弃了，交给了AI，把仅剩的创造力用于满足自己的感官体验。不过他们一点都不担心，因为他们认定宇宙本身就已经有了无限的可能性，不需要他们去努力创造。
In an Earth human perspective, our mother nature gives us the ability to think and allows us to create more odds for mother nature itself. Perhaps this is the purpose of the universe. The Guokers however, gave up this ability to AI. All their creations left are for satisfying their own senses. But anyway, they're not worried about this at all. They're already convinced that the universe itself can create all odds without the help of their own work.
那么再谈精神控制的问题，果克人能免受精神控制的奴役吗？显然不可能。他们的意识是被AI规划的，他们的自由意志/自由选择权能有多大呢？也许他们认为只要物质上实现自由就够了，剩下便没有什么别的需求了。人类的生活过得如此困难，还要努力学习，对他们来说才是一种苦，是一种奴役。这一点上真的不好评论，因为人类自己真正想要什么、追求什么，仍然没有想清楚。当各种外星科技放在我们面前——就像各种玩具放在孩子面前的时候，孩子怎么选就会成为什么样的人，那我们人类准备好选择哪条科技树了吗？我们想清楚自己应该成为什么样的文明了吗？
Back to the topic of mind control, are the Guokers free from mind control? Obviously not. Their own consciousness is limited by AI, so how much freedom of will do they have? Or maybe it's enough for them to have material freedom over mental freedom. To their perspective, Earth human beings have such a hard life - to study hard to become wise. Could that constant struggle for intelligence be a kind of slavery?
It is not easy to judge. We humans don't really understand what we want. When we were confronted with all kinds of alien technology - just like toys in front of a toddler when he/she would grow into the kind of person based on what toy he/she choose, are we ready to pick our own tech tree? Are we clear what kind of civilization we want to be?
建筑架构 Architecture
免物流的生产经济 Logistics-free economy
张祥前对果克星球的第一印象就是巨大的虚拟建筑挤在一起，根本没有道路和各种交通工具。他们只有娱乐性的载客交通工具，悬浮在人头顶上慢速行驶以保证安全运行。
Zhang's first impression of Guoker Planet is gigantic virtual buildings packed together without roads inbetween. They also don't have means of transport on the planet surface orther than recreational hover cars above people's heads to avoid traffic accidents.
其根本原因在于，人工场的瞬移技术将物流这一概念彻底消灭了。
The fundamental reason is that the artificial field teleportation technology has completely eliminated the concept of logistics.
作为人类，如果你是工厂主，你在一片土地上建设工厂时，首先考虑的一定是物流。如果你要经营一家商店，那一定要考虑地段和客流的问题。如果你要规划一座城市，那一定要考虑水利工程方面的问题。人类的工程学本质上就是解决从A点到B点的问题。果克人工场解决了一切从A点到B点的问题，所有的东西都可以光速瞬间移动。于是星球上的所有物资都不需要运输，也就不需要任何交通工具和管道。建筑物当然就可以彻底不考虑物流。人的生存将不再需要靠近水源，不必再考虑水文因素。
As Earth human beings, if you want to build a factory, you need to consider logistics first. If you a running a shop, you need to consider location to have the most customers. If you are planning a city, you need to consider water engineering.
For Earth human beings, engineering is from A to B. The Guoker artificial field on the other hand, solved all the problems from A to B, because everything can be teleported. Hence, all material resources on the planet are not to be transported either by vehicles or by pipelines. Their buildings no longer need to consider logistics. Their cities no longer need water engineering in consideration.
因此，果克星的经济就出现了非常有趣的现象。其虚拟经济是高度去中心化的，而实体经济是高度集约化的。一颗星球上，一个生产行业，可能只有一家企业、一幢建筑。所以这幢建筑的体积会变得无比巨大，为的就是能够满足整颗星球上所有人对其产品的需求。它极有可能是前店后厂模式，顾客之间传送到店里消费，商品生产完成以后直接传送给消费者，真正的没有中间商赚差价、厂家直销、精益去库存。
So it becomes interesting to ovserve the Guoker economy. They have a highly decentralized virtual economy and a highly centralized material-based economy. On their planet, one industry might be covered by one company in one building. That is why their buildings are all enormously large - to fit the need of the entire planet. It is also very likely that the building is the factory and the store combined together. Customers can be teleported to the factory to consume the goods on-site, and goods can be teleported directly to households.
要是地球上通过人工场消灭了物流的话，那人类现有的所有城市都会被拆除，变回自然资源，人类将在人迹罕至的沙漠、山区和冰原建造由巨型虚拟建筑组成的城市。所有的农产品将在最适合其生长的地区自然种植，并由人工场照料，自动采摘后传送到消费者手里。如果人类也像果克人一样无需饮食，则农业将不再需要种植粮食，而是以能够生产各种药品的经济作物为主。
If this happens on Earth, all our cities, which currently located in natrual resource rich areas, will be demolished and returned to mother nature. We would build our cities in very rural areas like deserts, mountains and icelands. Our agriculture would be placed in the best locations. Artificial field can take care of the plants, harvest and teleport the fruits directly to our dining table. If we were like the Guokers outsourcing our metabolism, then we would never need to grow food. Instead, plants for producing medicines and neural-active chemicals would be the major agricultural species.
免费能源可能永远无法实现 Free energy might be impossible for Guokers
在张祥前的书中，果克人只提到了太阳能与核能。我们人类传说中的免费能源并没有出现。这里不用提能量守恒定律，而是应该思考如何去定义免费能源。如果从自然界获取场能就是免费能源的话，果克人是一定能做到的，但他们的基础设施对能源的消耗实在太大了，因此太阳能成了他们最有效率的能源。可想而知，没有太阳能，果克人的虚拟和实体经济都会崩溃，在虚拟世界生活的人们都会死亡。我们还缺乏足够的信息来判断人工场是否可以在可控核聚变上实现正向的投入产出比，但结合果克人的生活现状，核能很可能是无法满足其人工场技术对能源的巨量消耗的。
In Zhang's book, the Guokers only mentioned solar energy and nuclear energy. The most expected free energy is not mentioned. Regardless of conservation of energy theorem, we should first make it clear: what is the definition of free energy? If free energy is to extract field energy from empty space in the universe, it's hard to imagine that the Guokers were unable to do that. Maybe it's just too power-consuming to support the Guoker planetary infrastructure, so solar energy becomes the most efficient energy source for them. Obviously, without a star, the entire Guoker race will collpase, and all their people living in the virtual world will die.
We do not have enough information to know if it's cost-effective to use artificial field for controlled nuclear fusion. But considering what they do, it is probably that nuclear energy would be insufficient for the high consumption Guoker lifestyle.
因此，果克人在能源方面的收支平衡始终是问题，对他们来说，免费能源可能永远无法实现。他们最珍视的是信息，但这些信息都是用能源换来的。他们的太阳最终能换取多少信息呢？
In conclusion, it remains a problem of budgeting energy consumption for the Guokers. Free energy might be never accomplishable for them. What they cherish the most is information, of the cost of energy. How much information could they trade with their own sun eventually?
生物学 Evolution
肉管子的进化学分析 Evolutionary analysis of "meat pipes"
在地球上，果克肉管子的结构可能只见于枝吻纽虫，或海葵等海洋生物。海水里有浮力，因此肉管子只需要平滑肌就可以实现摄食功能，一旦它被捞上来，在重力的影响下就会变得软塌塌的。果克肉管子看上去是一种拥有骨骼肌和丰富神经元的器官（暂且排除人工场帮忙移动的可能性），其如果在地球陆地生物上使用，则对于生物体的功重比有不利影响，即消耗更多体力又徒增重量。尤其是在口腔和直肠处如果有肉管子，则会因为频繁的进食和排泄产生损坏和感染，不利于生物的生存进化。可能地球生物都有一条单独的舌头，是对肉管子功能性的最大平衡。
On Earth, similar structure to the Guoker meat pipes can only be seen on nemertea or sea anemone. The floating force of water can support the weight of meat pipes, so they only need smooth muscles to ensure the feeding function of meat pipes, which they become floppy on land. If it's not powered by the artificial field, the Guoker meat pipes should have strong skeletal muscles to move on land and rich neurons to enhance feelings. For Earth creatures, this structure has disadvantage in power-to-weight ratio - which is heavy and energy consuming. Especially when they were located in the mouth or anus, they were prone to damage and infection due to the frequent feeding. Maybe the tongue of Earth creatures is the most we can have.
果克星上的生物，尤其有智慧的生物，大都拥有肉管子。这也许也是一种进化优势，因为它们在不需要进食的情况下，肉管子可以强化体验，才会进化地越来越多，将传统生物结构淘汰。
Guoker intelligent creatures mostly have meat pipes probably as evolutionary advantage. They don't consume food, and they need stronger feeling, so they have more. Creatures without meat pipes are obsolete on the market.
肉管子收纳后，从结构上讲，有些类似小肠绒毛。结合果克人从口腔到下体整个都是一个收纳肉管子的结构，则有可能是将肠道及其神经系统一并改为了性器官，仍符合原口动物的特性。
The inner cavity from throat to groin of the Guoker human body can retract the meat pipes, and structurally, it looks like intestine villus. Suppose they still belong to protostomia, but the whole digest system with its neural system was completely rebuilt into sex organ.
尤其有趣的是，果克的女性不需要生育，其身体空腔经历了反客为主的进化，最终导致的结果很可能是男性因为体验方面的进化劣势被淘汰，男性意识最终退隐到虚拟世界。（考虑到他们的意识受到限制无法实现实体上的性别转换）这一点张祥前没有描述，毫无疑问是果克文明在社会学方面非常值得研究的一点。
It is perticularly intresting that the Guoker females changed from passive to active in sex relations due to the change to their body structure. They can never get pregnant and they can turn their sex organ from inside out to mate. It might lead to the result that the males become obsolete in evolution. Since they cannot be transsexuals in body form, their males might end up retreating to the virtual world. Despite not mentioned in Zhang's book, it is an important socialogical topic to research.
身体结构简化的结果 The outcome of simplified body anatomy
如前文提到，果克人将身体功能外包给外部工具，因此连消化系统和呼吸系统都被精简了，只剩下用于强化体验的身体结构、运动系统与神经系统。对于他们的医疗来说，无疑有很大的好处。这样会让果克人的人造身体有很强的抗病性，且易于用人工场进行理化治疗。成瘾性精神药物对于他们来说也是来也匆匆去也匆匆的状态，让果克人能够承受高强度的感官刺激，而不必担心对身体器官的损害。由于我们无法知道果克人体内的激素和神经递质是如何工作的，但可以想象，它一定比人类更简单直接高效，就如同西药与中草药的区别。
As mentioned above, the Guokers outsource their body functions to external tools, so their bodies no longer require digestive and respiratory systems. Only the muscles and nerves are preserved for enhanced experience. This gives great convenience to their medicine. So the Guoker human bodies are robust, resilient to diseases and easily healed by physical and chemical treatments. Addictive psychotropic drugs are also easy come easy go for them. Thus the Guokers are capable to withstand highly intensive sense stimulations without worrying about damaging any internal organs. Though we cannot know how hormones and neuro-transmitters work in their bodies, but it is imaginable that they must be highly efficient compared to Earth humans', just like comparing chemical drugs with natural herbs.
对比人类，我们人类的每一个器官都会产生其特定的化学物质，必须是各器官达到平衡和协同才能让身体健康。因此人类的医疗变得复杂而困难。过度的感官刺激和各种药品终究会导致人体器官的损坏，进而导致人的精神出现异常，并且最终反映成为社会问题。这可以理解为，人类社会各种繁杂严格的管理制度，终究是来自于人体本身为了适应地球恶劣环境而进化出的复杂脆弱性。相比之下，要管理果克人，其重心就放在了较为简单的方面，比如他们需要与对邪恶的好奇心作斗争。这都是一个文明形态存续所需要付出的代价。文明的发展就是被这些问题和代价推着、被自己的优势拉着往前走的，也许我们都不会意识到自己的文明会被推向哪里。
All organs of us Earth humans can produce their unique chemical compounds. There is a balance of all the organs to make us healthy. That is why we have such a complexity in our medicine. Excessive stimulations and drugs will eventually cause damage to our organs, which will eventually lead to mental problems, and eventually end up in social unrest. You can understand from this perspective that all the complex and strict regulations on Earth are from our vulnerabilities evolved to survive the hazards on Earth - a price we must pay. The Guokers in comparison, should concern about simpler factors, such as confronting the curiosity in evil - that is a price their civilization needs to pay to survive. All civilizations have their own problems to solve and price to pay. Maybe that's the driving factor of development, along with the advantages pulling the civilization forward. Maybe we would never know what would lead us to which direction.
语言学 Linguistics
果克人虽然能够通过人工场实现脑际沟通，但这种沟通仍然是基于语言的。也许他们还可以用人工场进行化学物质沟通，但这一切的基础都是所谓的“人工信息场截频技术”。大胆猜测，这种截频技术有自身极大的局限性。
Although the Guokers can communicate brain-to-brain via artificial field, this communication is still based on language. Maybe it's possible to communicate through chemicals via artificial field, but both of these methods are based on the "artificial information field frequency interception technology". I would wildly guess that the information interception technology has its unbreakable limit.
这里解释一下我的看法：语言是一维的，而由空间流组成的世界是四维时空。我们的每一次语言交流，都是一次降维再升维的过程，因而产生了信息损失。
My theory is that language is one-dimensional. Our universe, based on spatial flow, is three-dimensional in space plus one dimension of time. Communication through language is shrinking 4D reality to 1D code, then translate back to 4D again. This will lose information.
这在书中被证实了，果克人在向人工信息场下达命令时必须做一个动作，否则AI仍然会误解。因为截频技术要把人的意图翻译成一维语言，再交给AI做价值判断。降维的信息承载能力差，就更容易出错，把偏离放大化。
It is proved in this book that the Guokers need to make a certain posture to confirm their command to the artificial information field. Otherwise the AI can still confuse, because frequency interception is translating multi-dimensional thought to one-dimensional language, then the AI judges its value with math. While information is downgraded to lower dimension, its deviation will be enlarged, due to lower dimension is unable of supporting the complexity of information from higher dimension.
我们必须意识到一个问题，探索我们自己的意识，不能以语言为基础。一定要了解那个多维度的感受，感受想法、脑中图景和声音是怎么产生的，感受逻辑是怎么如闪电一般接通的。
We need to understand the fact that exploring our own consciousness cannot be complete only by language. We must understand that in multi-dimension. Just feel yourself, how are your thoughts, mind pictures and sounds appeared? How are your logics connect like lightning strikes in your brain?
理解了这一点，也就理解了为什么AI只能创造出幻象。只要AI基于一维逻辑语言运行，没有打通多维的渠道，那它能够承载的意识终究有一个局限性，无论它各方面能比人类强出成千上万倍。AI的伟大只不过是人类集体意识积累的伟大，AI的强力只不过是人类意志和欲念的强力。制造工具、依赖工具，但不要忘了超越工具。
By understanding this, we would learn that AI is delusional. As long as AI runs on the basis of one-dimensional logic language, as long as AI fails to break through the multi-dimensional conduits, AI would still have limits supporting consciousness, despite it being thousands of times more powerful than humans in every aspect. The power of AI is the power of accumulated collective consciousness of humans. The might of AI is the extension of will-power of humans. We can create tools and depend on tools, but we should never forget to think beyond our tools.