Chapter 17: The Haunting Never Left
Kayla tried to convince herself that everything was normal. That she wasn't overthinking her last conversation with Caston. That she wasn't looking for him every time she walked into a room.
That she wasn't waiting for him to call her bluff.
But none of that mattered now. Because something else was happening.
Something worse.
------------------
"Did you hear that?"
Laura's whisper barely cut through the silence of the library basement.
Kayla's grip on her flashlight tightened. "Yeah, I heard it."
It had started a week ago—faint whispers in the hallways when no one was there. Strange shadows stretching too long against the walls. The unmistakable feeling of being watched.
But now? Now it wasn't just a feeling.
Now it was real.
Marina shivered, pressing closer to Rose. "Tell me again why we thought breaking into the locked archives was a good idea?"
"Because," Rose whispered, "this school is hiding something. And if we don't figure it out, we're next."
Laura flipped through an old yearbook they had found buried in the archives. The pages were yellowed, some stuck together with something that Kayla didn't want to think about.
"Look at this," Laura said, pointing.
A black-and-white picture of a girl. Hazel eyes. A solemn expression. But it wasn't just the picture—it was the caption.
Elaine Carter – Missing, 1953.
"She was the first," Laura murmured. "The first reported disappearance from Ridgewood High."
Kayla frowned. "You're saying there were more?"
Laura turned the page.
More pictures. More names. More missing students.
Their chests tightened.
"Why isn't this in the school records?" Marina asked.
"Because someone doesn't want us to know," Rose said.
The air shifted. Cold. Wrong.
And then—
A loud crash from the back of the basement.
Kayla spun, flashlight beam shaking.
Nothing.
But she knew—knew they weren't alone.
Laura swallowed hard. "We should go."
Rose nodded. "Agreed."
But as they turned, something whispered—low and rasping, a voice that didn't belong to anyone.
"You shouldn't be here."
Kayla's blood turned to ice.
The lights flickered—once, twice—then died completely.
And the screaming started.
---
Back at school the next day…
Kayla didn't know how she was supposed to act like nothing happened.
She barely remembered how they got out of the basement. Just that the shadows moved, that the air had pressed in around them like a living thing, that something whispered in her ear as she ran—
"You'll be next."
She shivered.
"You good?"
She jumped at Caston's voice.
He stood beside her, hands shoved into his pockets, eyes scanning her face. And for the first time in forever, he didn't look cocky. Or smug. Or like he was waiting to get under her skin.
He looked… concerned.
And Kayla hated that it made her chest tighten.
"I'm fine," she said quickly.
He didn't buy it.
"Try again."
She scowled. "None of your business."
Caston sighed, rubbing a hand down his face. "You are exhausting."
"Then stop talking to me."
He leaned in just enough to make her breath hitch. "Not happening."
Kayla hated how warm his presence felt. How steady. How safe.
She did not need Caston Wright to protect her.
Especially not from ghosts.