Everyone present was taken aback.
The young man continued, "I am no expert, but I have some study in appraising antiques, and I just so happen to have a deep understanding of Shen Dai's carving style and all of his works."
"Shen Dai's flower carvings have always emphasized smooth lines. This White Jade Orchid Blossom Vase is founded on those smooth lines, but with an even greater difficulty. The petals are layered to emphasize depth, with varying sizes of buds about to bloom, and the root of the orchid fades naturally in its greenish-white jade color."
"But if we look at this piece before us, the lines of the petals are slightly rigid, the buds lack vivacity and finesse, and the gradation of color in the root does not appear natural and fluid."
"More importantly, the overall luster and brightness of this jade carving is a shade lower than that of the genuine article, lacking the true piece's lustrous and clear beauty."