The restaurant had been Ellie's idea. A dimly lit, candle-flickering escape from reality, somewhere she could pretend—just for one night—that she and Ben were normal again. That their relationship wasn't infested with the lingering presence of his dead ex-girlfriend.
But as she sat across from him, swirling her wine in its glass, she could feel it.
The air was wrong.
Thick.
Heavy.
Cold.
Ben was trying. She could tell. His smile was softer than it had been in days, his fingers brushing against hers as if testing the waters of her affection. But Ellie wasn't stupid.
Victoria was watching.
She took a slow sip of her wine, her fingers tightening around the stem of the glass. "This is nice, right?" she murmured, forcing a smile. "Us. A normal night."
Ben nodded. "Yeah, it is." His voice was careful. Almost hesitant.
Ellie's heart ached.
She wanted to believe him.
But then the lights flickered.
A soft breeze coiled around her neck like unseen fingers, and Ellie froze.
Ben stiffened. "Ellie—"
The candle at the center of their table flared, the flame stretching unnaturally high before snuffing out completely.
The restaurant darkened.
Ellie's pulse spiked. "No. No, not tonight." She gritted her teeth, her fingers digging into the table. "Victoria, stay the hell out of this."*
A soft, mocking laugh slithered through the room.
Ellie's stomach dropped.
The air around them shifted. The shadows curled along the floor, slithering toward their table like something alive.
Ben exhaled sharply, his hand reaching for Ellie's. "We should go."*
"No." Ellie yanked her hand back. "I won't let her ruin this."
A whisper brushed against her ear, sending ice through her veins.
"He doesn't even want you here."*
Ellie's blood ran cold.
Her chair scraped against the floor as she stood, her heart hammering against her ribs. "Show yourself, you coward."*
The whisper came again, this time behind her.
"You really think he'll ever love you like he loved me?"
Ellie whirled around, but there was nothing there.
Just emptiness.
Ben was on his feet now too, his face pale, his hands clenched into fists. "Victoria, stop this!"*
The chandelier above them shook. The other patrons in the restaurant were oblivious, their conversations continuing as if nothing was happening.
This was for them alone.
A private nightmare.
Ellie turned back to Ben, her throat tight. "Tell me, Ben."* Her voice was sharp, almost dangerous. "Did you really want this date? Or was it just guilt?"
Ben swallowed, his gaze flickering with something she couldn't quite read. "Ellie, I love you—"
The glasses on the table shattered.
Ellie flinched.
And then, right there, in the reflection of the broken glass—she saw her.
Victoria.
Standing behind Ben, her face inches from his.
Smiling.
Ellie's breath hitched, her stomach twisting.
Because Ben…
Ben hadn't even noticed.