unique league system

Liam Carter had no idea that his mixed heritage had already sparked debates online. While discussions about his background spread, he was fully focused on preparing for the upcoming Scottish Premier League season with Dundee United.

Dundee United had won the Scottish FA Cup last season, which normally would have earned them a place in a Super Cup match. However, Scottish football was unique—it had no Super Cup.

Historically, Scotland was one of the first leagues to introduce a Super Cup, but due to World War II, the competition was halted. After the war, disputes arose about which teams should qualify, leading to its permanent suspension. Unlike other leagues that revived their Super Cups, Scotland simply never brought it back.

This was a common trait of smaller European leagues—they often had unique competition structures compared to the Big Five leagues.

One key difference was the number of teams. In the Premier League, La Liga, Bundesliga, Serie A, and Ligue 1, each league had at least 18 to 20 teams. Smaller leagues, however, often had far fewer.

If a small league followed the traditional home-and-away format seen in the Big Five, they would play fewer matches per season, leading to issues such as:

Lower fan engagement due to fewer games.

Less revenue from broadcasting and sponsorships.

Poor match fitness, making it harder to compete in European tournaments.

For example, the Scottish Premiership only had 12 teams. If they used a straight two-round format, each team would only play 22 league games per season—less than half the number of matches in bigger leagues.

That meant a team might only play once every two weeks, making it difficult to maintain form and fitness for competitions like the Champions League or Europa League.

To counter this, smaller leagues implemented creative solutions—one of the most common being the regular season plus playoff system.

In many European leagues, after two round-robin phases, teams were split into groups:

The Championship Group, where the top teams fought for the title and European spots.

The Relegation Group, where the bottom teams fought to avoid the drop.

This structure helped increase the number of matches and provided more entertainment value for fans.

Unlike other small European leagues, Scotland used a three-round format.

Each club played against the other 11 teams three times, leading to 33 matches in the regular season.

Once those rounds were completed, the league split into two groups:

The top six clubs entered the Championship Group, where they played five more games against each other.

The bottom six teams entered the Relegation Group, where they also played five more games to determine relegation.

By doing this, the league stretched the total matches to 38—the same as the English Premier League.

It was almost as if the Scottish FA deliberately structured the league to match England, even if the format itself was entirely different.

Yet, while Scotland's system was unusual, it wasn't the strangest in the world of football.

For instance, Austria had an even more extreme system—a four-round format. Since they had only 10 teams, each club faced the others four times, leading to a 36-match season—slightly fewer than Scotland's 38.

Then there was Major League Soccer (MLS) in the United States, which used a completely different structure compared to Europe.

Instead of a single-table system, MLS copied the NBA's model, splitting teams into Eastern and Western Conferences. This meant that clubs played some opponents once, some twice, and some three or more times.

Even stranger, MLS originally had no draws—every match had to have a winner. If a game was tied after 90 minutes, teams competed in a bizarre "shootout" system.

This wasn't a normal penalty shootout. Instead, players would dribble in from 35 yards out and take on the goalkeeper one-on-one, trying to score within five seconds.

The idea was meant to make soccer more exciting for American audiences, but it was so unpopular that MLS eventually abandoned it.

Yet, if MLS's format was strange, Argentina's league took things to a whole new level.

Unlike most leagues, which relegated teams based on that season's performance, Argentina introduced a five-season average points system.

This meant that instead of simply sending down the worst three teams of the current season, the Argentine FA calculated each club's average points over five years. The three worst-performing clubs in that ranking were relegated.

The logic behind this was to prevent big clubs from being relegated due to one bad season. But in practice, it led to absurd results.

For instance, a club that had been struggling for years could suddenly invest in strong players, have a fantastic season, qualify for the Copa Libertadores, and then still be relegated because their five-year average was too low.

This actually happened. A team qualified for the Copa Libertadores but was relegated that same season.

Even worse, in a theoretical scenario, a team could win the Argentine league title and still be relegated due to their five-year record.

The Argentine FA insisted that this was the fairest system ever, but most football fans disagreed.

While other football federations had also made questionable decisions, Argentina's relegation system remained one of the most controversial and confusing in football history.

---

August 14, 2010 – The Start of the Scottish Premiership

On Saturday, August 14, 2010, the 2010/11 Scottish Premiership season officially kicked off.

Dundee United's first match was an away fixture against St. Mirren, a club that barely survived relegation last season.

Liam Carter was included in the match squad but did not start. Instead, he was brought on as a substitute in the second half.

However, his league debut was far from ideal.

Despite sending in two excellent crosses, his teammates failed to convert them, and Dundee United was held to a 1-1 draw.

It was clear that St. Mirren had done their homework. They assigned a physically dominant defender to shadow Liam throughout the match, limiting his influence.

As he walked off the pitch, he couldn't help but recall the conversation he had with manager Peter Houston before the season started.

"Liam, your technique is great," Houston had said, "but if you want to survive in this league, you need to build your strength."

Now, Liam finally understood what his manager meant.

In British football, skill alone wasn't enough. If he wanted to succeed, he needed to bulk up, get stronger, and learn to handle physical defenders.

Otherwise, no matter how talented he was, he would always struggle to make an impact.

---