Penny Carter had never considered herself superstitious, but she also wasn't stupid.
The eerie encounter at Oliver's Curiosities still clung to her like cobwebs in the back of her mind, but she refused to entertain the idea that anything about this desk was actually unusual. It was just furniture. A very heavy, ridiculously stubborn piece of furniture that she now regretted dragging up two flights of stairs by herself.
She gritted her teeth, wedging herself between the doorframe and the desk's bulky weight. "Come on, you piece of—"
She shoved. The desk didn't budge.
Another push. Still nothing.
Frustration burned in her chest. She braced her shoulder against the side and gave it one last, determined heave—
BANG.
The desk smacked against the wall with a dull, hollow thud. Penny winced. That probably left a mark.
Then something shifted.
Not outside the desk—inside it.
She froze.
The sound had been unmistakable. A soft, muffled scrape, followed by the faintest thunk, like something small had been dislodged.
Penny's pulse spiked.
Slowly, she knelt beside the desk, running her hands over the scuffed wood, feeling for… what, exactly? A hidden drawer? A loose panel? The idea sent a chill across her skin, but her curiosity was stronger than her unease.
Fingers trembling slightly, she traced the ornate carvings along the desk's side. Her touch skimmed over the surface until—
Click.
A whisper of a sound. A breath of movement.
And then, to her absolute disbelief, a narrow compartment slid open along the side of the desk, revealing a hollow space no bigger than a shoebox.
Penny's breath hitched.
Inside, tucked in a neat, almost reverent stack, were letters.
Not one. Not two. Dozens.
She reached in, fingers brushing against the brittle edges of envelopes yellowed with age. The ink on the topmost letter was faded but still legible.
And when she read the name on the envelope, her stomach flipped.
Penny Carter.
Her own name.
Her vision blurred for a second, her mind scrambling for an explanation. This had to be a mistake. A coincidence. A leftover from a previous owner who just happened to share her name—right?
But Penny had never met another Penny Carter. And even if she had, what were the chances that her desk—one she hadn't even planned on buying—would be hiding letters meant for someone with her exact name?
Her throat tightened as she turned the envelope over. The seal had been broken. Someone had opened this before.
Swallowing hard, she unfolded the letter with shaking hands and read the first line.
"You won't believe me, Penny. Not at first. But I need you to trust me."
A chill danced down her spine.
She skimmed ahead, eyes darting across the elegant, looping handwriting. It wasn't just a letter. It was a love letter.
Her breath came faster now, her heartbeat a frantic drum in her chest.
"…I don't know how much time we have, but I love you. I always have. And I will find you again."
Penny gripped the paper so tightly it nearly tore.
This wasn't possible. This wasn't real.
But then she saw the signature.
A name. One she didn't recognize, but that sent an inexplicable shockwave through her anyway.
Theo.
Her hands trembled.
Who the hell was Theo?
And how did he know her?