Chapter 5: Smile like you mean it

I didn't sleep that night.

Not just because I kept staring at the envelope with You're the key written in fancy serial killer font.

Not even because the reflection I didn't have was still haunting every shiny surface.

No. I didn't sleep because around 3 a.m., I heard laughter.

In my mirror.

Soft. Familiar.

Like my voice, if you handed it to something with teeth.

***

The next day was worse.

Not scary-worse. Off-worse.

Like everything was slightly tilted, and no one else noticed the floor wasn't level anymore.

Classes were quiet. Too quiet.

People whispered like someone had died, but no one said who. The school had this heavy stillness, like it was holding its breath, waiting for something to shatter.

And then Liam walked in.

---

Now, Liam's not important. He's… background noise. The guy who always asks to copy your homework and somehow still fails. The type to vape in the bathroom and call it "spiritual meditation."

But today?

Today Liam was different.

Too… clean.

Too straight.

Like someone ironed the personality out of him.

He walked down the hall like he'd been programmed. Same backpack. Same walk. Same haircut.

Except his eyes?

Empty.

And when he smiled at me—slow, symmetrical, perfect—my skin went ice cold.

Because I realized something horrifying:

He'd never smiled at me before.

---

I backed away. Tried to act normal. You know, like you do when someone might be a reflection trying to possess your face.

And when I looked back?

He was still watching me.

Still smiling.

Still too perfect.

I booked it to the library.

---

"You noticed," the girl said before I even opened my mouth.

She was already sitting in the back corner. No books. Just her boots on the table and a mirror in her lap—wrapped in velvet and string, like a murder gift.

I sat down hard. "You didn't tell me they could fully replace people."

"I did," she said. "You just weren't ready to hear it."

"Well, I'm definitely not ready now either," I snapped. "So congrats on consistency."

She didn't flinch.

"Was it Liam?" she asked.

I paused. "...I think so."

"Yeah. We lost him two nights ago."

I blinked. "You KNEW? And just—what? Let him walk around being possessed like a walking Google ad?!"

She held my gaze. "We can't save everyone."

Oh. Cool. That's totally comforting.

Not traumatic at all. Thanks, mirror goth girl.

---

She slid the mirror toward me. I didn't want to look.

She nodded once. "It's safer in here than out there."

"I disagree with literally every part of that sentence," I muttered.

But I looked anyway.

Still nothing. Just my hoodie, my messed-up hair—and no reflection.

Just blank space where I should be.

And then...

A handprint smudged the inside of the glass.

From the other side.

---

I jerked back. Nearly knocked over my chair.

She didn't move.

"You're waking it up," she whispered.

"I'M WHAT?"

"The more you know," she said, "the more it knows you."

Oh. Amazing.

Absolutely love that for me.

"So what do we do?" I asked, breath shaky.

She met my eyes, her voice cold as cracked glass:

"We find the mirror gate.

Before it finds you."