Moroes, the Tower Steward

Were there any more items?

Yes!

"What is this? It's a Badge of Justice, but it doesn't seem like an equippable item. I got three of them," Remnant Dream took out two items that looked like coins.

"Oh, I think this is the exchangeable currency that the official site mention that could be exchanged for equipment at Shattrath City. Because it's Nightmare difficulty, everyone will get three, so let's go up and get it," Lu Li also went and looted. Fortunately, he got three as well, instead of two or one. Otherwise, it would've only further validated his misfortune.

Thank the heavens!

Badge of Justice could not be traded. The equipment you exchanged the Badge of Justice for also couldn't be traded.