Chapter Sixty Six: My Pain Is Your Pain

Elijah's POV: After we got Hayley we stuck her in the basement of our mansion, I kept it here untouched after all this time Incase I needed to stick another one of my siblings down here, I had to do it to Katerina before, so I figured if it could break Katerina then it could break Hayley. But she is strong, maybe not stronger than "Katherine" but Hayley was pretty strong. I just hoped she wouldn't hate me when her emotions were back on...

Hayley's POV: Elijah, Nik and Kaylee grabbed me, I didn't expect it because they were the ones who told me to turn my emotions off. So why were they trying to turn them back on, I've only killed a few people. Ok a lot of people, but I like it this way, no emotions...no problems. Well that's what I thought at first until I realized how needy and clingy those Pierre boys are. Oh well, they won't break me without a fight...

Klaus's POV: I made Elijah and Kaylee leave so I could try to do things my way, the nice way. I asked Hayley with kindness if she'd turn her emotions back on, and I gave her about a million good reasons to also! She wouldn't budge, so I let Kaylee give it a go. She tried to use magic to find her weak spot and use it against her. And to my surprise, her weak spot, according to Kaylee, was Elijah. I guess she really did love him. But threatening him didn't do anything for her. She had another weak spot that we'd have to find in order to turn her emotions back on. Elijah and I took Hayley up to the room in the house with the most windows, we tied her to a chair and took her daylight ring off so if light hit her, she'd start to burn. That might have been taking it to far but an emotionless Hayley is like a Clarissa 2.0, not good for anyone. Anyway, we had the sunlight hidden by a curtain, we kept opening it very slowly, then closing it again in hope that she'd start to feel pain at least, it was an emotion after all and if we could get her to feel pain about that then we could get her emotions back on easily...

Hayley's POV: Elijah and Nik thought they were smart by burning me, but I knew better, I was still strong from all the blood I had so with that little bit of strength I had left I ripped he ropes they tied me down with, ran up to the curtain and ripped it down letting myself burn. But I knew what they'd do next, they took the fire extinguisher and put the fire out before it could burn me to death and shut the curtains. I told them that I knew they wouldn't break me or do anything to hurt me, so with that I took my daylight ring back from Elijah, and whispered in his ear saying "If you ever try to turn my emotions on again, I will go on a killing spree, starting with Kaylee and ending with the two of you!" They clearly took it seriously because they let me leave with ease, however I should've known they'd have a plan b. They had Kaylee put a spell on the house keeping me, Nik and Elijah trapped. Any vampire that entered wouldn't leave until Kaylee broke the spell. And I had to keep my word by killing Kaylee, so I ran everywhere trying to find her, but I was to late. Nik has put her outside telling her not to release the spell until they said, and not to come inside no matter what. Ugh, why did they have to make everything so complicated...

Klaus's POV: After Hayley realized that she couldn't leave or kill anyone she searched the whole house in hope to find a stake or something, luckily we had Kaylee confiscate our entire supply of stakes, even though we can't be killed by one, it would give her time to do who knows what. So we wanted to take extra precaution with her. We also had Kaylee bringing us supplies of blood. Just enough to keep us stronger than Hayley. She wouldn't get any because it would make her strong also, we wanted to keep her as weak as possible without desiccating her. We continued to torture her. We all didn't like it, it was almost like we could feel her pain but she couldn't. So we decided to take it up a notch. We ripped the leg off a chair for a stake, I stabbed her without thinking twice, I knew what I was doing, I scraped her heart with it. She was feeling pain. But not enough, so I left Elijah, the ultimate torturer, to do it himself. In the meantime I was going to sleep because I haven't in like 2 days...

Elijah's POV: Niklaus left me to do the torturing, he said he was going to sleep for awhile. So I knew what I had to do to get her emotions back on, I had to snap her neck and right before she comes back to life I would get inside her head and find out her true weakness since she wouldn't be awake to block me from seeing it. So that's what I did, I snapped her neck. She was about to wake up a few hours later and that's when I got into her head, I dug deep into her mind to find out what she was hiding from all of us. Her weak spot was a guy, someone she's known her whole life, a best friend, his name was Simon. She'd never mentioned him before and I think this is why, if we ever needed a way to get to her that would be it, there was a lot of people she cared about like Matt, Jenny, Kaylee, Niklaus, Caroline and I, but Simon was the one that she's known since she was a baby, someone she grew up with. And someone she dated. Oh wow, I didn't think it'd be that deep but I guess so. It didn't work out and it was still a little awkward but she'd never want anything bad to happen to him. She told him all about vampires and everything she was. And she gave him a ring, and old family heirloom. I got all that from digging into her mind and before she woke up I locked her in the cell and did some research on the ring since I knew her family knew about vampires. Apparently the ring protects people from supernatural deaths. Matt had one too! But it'd be better to use Simon since he's so close with her and he knows about vampires...