Hearing Wakefield's early cries to ceasefire and surrender, some constables, including surveyor Cotterell, threw down their weapons and stood motionless. The pursuing warriors, incensed at the brutal and unprovoked attack on them, killed the constables without thought.
The first constables to cross the stream were all cut down, their blood tinting the water red. Devoid of life, other bodies littered the banks. Like red ribbons their blood trickled between the rocks, a tributary of life that eventually fed the hungry stream.
Men lay wounded, some screamed in agony, others called for mercy as warriors fell on them; silencing their cries by dispatching them with a quick thrust of a taiaha or a brutal club to the head.
Fortunate to be alive some men ran for their lives and managed to escape eventually reaching the safety of Nelson. Five constables were wounded, leaving twenty-two Pakeha bodies scattered across a small area.