57. Mystery Woman

Waverly grinned as she trotted through the front doors of the police station with her jacket slung over her forearm. She was on break and really wanted to see Nicole.

“Hey cutie!” She sang as she walked towards the redhead.

Nicole quickly looked up and smiled as soon as she saw Waverly walking towards her. “Hey, what are you doing here?”

“Just thought I’d pop by to see you.” Waverly hopped up to sit on the edge of Nicole’s desk beside her and crossed one jean-clad leg over the other. “I missed you.” She pouted as she reached out and grazed her index finger along the back of Nicole’s hand that was sitting on the computer keyboard.

Nicole let out a breathy chuckle. “Baby, we saw each other this morning. Remember? We spent an extra fifteen minutes lying in bed cuddling…”

“Oh, I remember. I didn’t want to get up.” Waverly sighed. “But still. Can’t I miss my baby after being without her for a few hours?”

“I guess,” Nicole shrugged with a grin as she turned her hand over to hold Waverly’s. “Besides, I might’ve missed you too.” She winked.

The corners of Waverly’s mouth turned up in a big smile, crinkling the corners of her eyes as she brushed her thumb along her palm while darting her eyes between the redhead’s brown irises and her soft lips.

“Haught!”

Waverly slid off of the desk and Nicole sat up straight in her chair as she peered over her computer screen at Nedley walking towards her. “Yes sir?”

“Pull up that report from that domestic violence call we got last week, would ya?”

“Yes sir.” She said with a short node before typing on her computer to pull up the database.

As soon as his eyes landed on Waverly, he gave a small smile. “And how are you today, Waverly?”

“I’m great!” She beamed with her hands clasped behind her back.

“And uh, Gus doing okay?”

Waverly nodded. “Yeah, she’s good. Keeping busy with the bar and stuff.”

“Good, good.” He nodded. “And how about Wynonna? You keeping her out of trouble?”

“As much as I can,” Waverly chuckled. “But she doesn’t need my help that much anymore. Ever since the baby, her responsible side has been showing…even if she hates it.”

He nodded as he gave a smile. “Good. When’s the due date?”

“March 10th.”

His eyes widened. “Well that’s coming up soon.”

Waverly grinned as she nodded. “Only two and a half weeks left! We’ve all been in baby mode. Practicing pregnancy drills, constantly going over the plan…all that stuff just in case the baby comes early. That way we’re not caught off guard.”

“Well I can’t wait to meet the little one.” He smiled before looking over at Nicole, who was printing out the papers.

“Here you go, sir!” Nicole handed Nedley the report as soon as it had finished printing, which he took appreciatively.

“Good. And I hope you’ll be finishing that task I gave you within the next hour.” He gave her a knowing look before flitting his eyes over towards Waverly, making sure there was no misunderstanding that Nicole was on the clock.

Nicole nodded confidently. “Yes sir. Working on it right now.”

“Good.” He gave Waverly a subtle wink before sauntering off towards his office and shutting the door behind him.

“Do you think he knows what we did on his couch that one time?” Waverly asked genuinely.

“Oh god, I hope not. I wouldn’t be able to look him in the eye ever again.” Nicole replied with a grimace.

Waverly nodded as she smirked. “Totally worth it though.”

Nicole pursed her lips and smiled as she slowly shook her head. “The responsible part of me wants to say it’s not, but the part of me that really enjoyed that day is saying that it is.”

“You should definitely listen to that last part of you.”

“Trust me, most of the time I am.” Nicole winked, causing Waverly to look at her with sultry eyes as she pulled her bottom lip between her teeth.

Waverly shook her head as she inhaled through her nose. “Well, I’ll let you get back to work. See you later, Officer Haught.” She gave Nicole a quick peck on the lips before heading off towards the exit.

“Hey Waverly!” Dolls greeted as he passed by the chipper brunette, who waved back at him with a grin before walking out the door.

“What’s got her in such a good mood?” He asked as he pointed over his shoulder with his thumb.

“Me.” Nicole smirked.

“Please tell me you didn’t just do what I think you did…” He grimaced.

Nicole furrowed her brow and shook her head. “No, Dolls, I meant from stopping by to see me. We were just talking.”

“Oh. Okay, good.” He let out a sigh of relief before sitting down in the chair across from her desk with a huge grin on his face. “So, I’ve got big news to share!”

“Ooh, tell me!” Nicole replied excitedly as she leaned back in her rolling chair to give him her undivided attention.

“I’ve been seeing someone.” He beamed as he got comfortable in the chair.

“That girl from Tinder?”

He shook his head. “Nah, that ended up not working out. She kept finishing my sentences so I ended that date early. But, I ended up meeting someone else when I went to the bar afterwards. And she’s amazing. She’s beautiful, cool, super easy to talk to, and when I told her I liked to watch Queer Eye, she didn’t even give me a weird look!”

“Wow, sounds like a match made in heaven,” Nicole replied sarcastically as she gave a light chuckle.

“I think it is. We’ve been on a date almost every night since.”

Nicole looked at him with a quirked eyebrow. “Are you sure you’re not a lesbian?”

“Ha ha, very funny.” He said as he narrowed his eyes at her. “I’m being serious. This girl is truly something special. Oh! And get this…she’s bisexual.” He nodded cheerfully before nonchalantly adding, “I mean, maybe you know her.”

Nicole rolled her eyes. “Why, because I’m a lesbian? I mean, do you really think all queer women know each other?”

He shrugged. “I don’t know, maybe? I mean, how many of you really are there?”

She narrowed her eyes at him. “A lot.”

He waved a hand in dismissal. “Well, either way, I’m bringing her by Shorty’s tonight. I was hoping you and Waverly could stop by to meet her? Wynonna should be there working. I want her to get to know my friends.” He nodded with a smile before looking up in thought. “…which I just realized are all women.” He shook his head as he inhaled through his nose. “I really need to get some more dude friends.”

Nicole chuckled with a slight shake of her head. “I’ll ask Waverly and see what she says.”

“Because you’re whipped?” He gave her a knowing look as he slowly folded his arms across his chest.

“No, because I don’t want to make plans for her without her.”

“…so, you’re saying you’re not whipped?”

“No, I am. Just not because of that.” Nicole shrugged before continuing her work.

---

“So, do I need to wear anything specific to meet this mystery woman tonight?” Waverly asked as she laid on Nicole’s bed while mindlessly petting Calamity Jane.

Nicole continued to scrub her body with soap from where she was standing under the shower water. “I don’t think so. Just wear whatever!” She yelled through the closed curtain and the opened bathroom door. A second later, she yanked back the curtain, revealing only her face and her collarbone, to add, “But if you wanted to wear that mini skirt and sweater that you look really good in, I wouldn’t be opposed.” A sly smile spread across her face as she teasingly bounced her eyebrows twice.

Waverly giggled as she stood up from the bed and strolled over into the ensuite bathroom. “Why? Are you trying to get laid or something?”

“I mean, if that ends up happening, I won’t be complaining,” Nicole replied with her head still poked around the curtain.

Waverly shook her head with an amused smile before giving Nicole a chaste kiss on her wet lips, enjoying the way the steam from the shower hit her face. When Nicole closed the curtain to finish up her shower, Waverly sat on top of the closed toilet lid beside the bathtub. “Do you ever think we have too much sex.”

“Um, no. Definitely not. There’s no such thing,” Nicole said from behind the curtain.

“Really? Because I feel like we have sex way more than other couples do. Even more than Wynonna did before she got pregnant, which I honestly never thought would happen to me…”

Nicole turned off the water with a squeak and pulled the curtain open all the way before grabbing her towel from the rack and wrapping it around her glistening body. She stepped over the side of the tub and onto the cushiony bath mat as she faced her girlfriend and shrugged. “I don’t think there’s anything wrong with how much sex we’re having. I mean, does it bother you?”

Waverly shook her head as she smiled. “Definitely not.”

“Then we’re doing it right!” Nicole dried her hair off with the towel before hanging it up to dry. She walked her naked body out of the bathroom and towards her closet to pick out some clothes.

Waverly slowly walked towards the bathroom door and leaned against the door frame with one hand wrapped around it as she looked over her girlfriend’s body. As her eyes roamed over the strong muscles, sexy curves, and smooth skin, she bit her bottom lip. She felt a flutter deep in the pit of her stomach, and she walked over towards Nicole. She wrapped her arms around the taller woman from where she stood behind her and rested her forehead against the taller woman’s smooth, soft back.

“I wanna have sex now,” Waverly whined as she shook her head, rolling her forehead back and forth.

Nicole chuckled as she turned around, wrapping her arms around the petite body as she rested her forehead against Waverly’s. “We still have about half an hour before we have to leave.”

Waverly felt Nicole wiggling her eyebrows against her own. “But, you just showered,” she replied in a soft tone as she ran her hands up and down Nicole’s back while looking at the woman’s lips.

Nicole slowly leaned in towards her ear and whispered, “I can take another one.” She smirked before pressing her lips against Waverly’s in a soft kiss.

Nicole ghosted her fingertips up Waverly’s arms and past her shoulders to cup the brunette’s face. They continued their slow kiss, feeling every centimeter of each other’s lips, as Nicole took her time unbuttoning Waverly’s blouse.

“Are you sure?” Waverly whispered against her girlfriend’s lips.

She looked down into attentive eyes and reached down to the button of Waverly’s pants, smoothly undoing it without breaking eye contact. Once she pulled the zipper down, she slipped her hand inside and smirked when she was greeted with the warm, wet feeling of Waverly’s slick arousal. A look of amusement spread across her face as Waverly knitted her eyebrows together and let out a small gasp while clenching tightly onto the sides of Nicole’s upper arms near her shoulders. She leaned in an inch or two and confidently replied, “I’m sure” before moving her fingers in slow, large, gentle circles around Waverly’s bud.

“Oh—fffff jesus” Waverly breathed out as she grabbed Nicole by the back of the neck with one hand – while keeping the other tightly held onto Nicole’s arm – and pulled her into a greedy kiss.

Nicole let out a breathy chuckle from her nose when she felt Waverly moan against her lips, earning her a slap in the arm.

“Don’t laugh at me!” Waverly whined, and Nicole immediately stopped and shook her head with a warm smile.

“I’m not, you’re just so cute. I love those little sounds you make. Let’s me know I’m doing my job right.” She gave a wink and a proud nod as she pulled her hand out, bringing her fingers up to her tongue with a smirk.

Waverly pursed her lips and shook her head as she desperately tried to hide her smile. “You’re so cocky.”

“Well, it’s warranted, isn’t it?” Nicole asked with a quirked eyebrow.

“Do you really want to stand here talking when we’re already down to 25 minutes?”

Nicole vigorously shook her head. “Absolutely not.” She pushed Waverly’s blouse off of her shoulders as Waverly simultaneously pushed down her jeans and underwear before reaching behind her own back and unhooking her bra, which Nicole immediately yanked off.

Waverly crawled backwards onto the bed, Nicole closely following her, before the redhead laid down on top of Waverly and picked up where they had left of with their heated kiss.

After a few seconds of Waverly dragging her nails along Nicole’s engaged obliques, she sat up and flipped them over to where she was straddling Nicole’s torso with her knees on either side of the bed. While sitting up, she reached up to put her long wavy locks up in a ponytail.

Nicole watched her girlfriend slightly rubbing her center against her pale abdomen, and with her bottom lip between her teeth she instantly reached a hand out. She placed her palm flat against Waverly’s trimmed curls over her pubic bone as she unexpectedly thumbed at her clit.

“Fuck” Waverly hissed at the unexpected touch. She quickly pulled her hair through the last twist of the band before dropping her hands down beside Nicole’s head and capturing the redhead’s bottom lip between her own. She pulled back, releasing it with a pop before whispering, “You’re so sexy.” She leaned down with a sultry smile and attempted to steal another kiss, but before their lips had connected Nicole smirked and smoothly slid down the bed. Waverly’s head slowly moved downward as her eyes followed Nicole’s moving down between her legs. With her mouth slightly agape and her eyes glued to brown ones looking back at her, she watched Nicole wrap her strong arms around her thighs before slowly moving her tongue out to glide around the sides of Waverly’s clit.

Waverly let out a breathy moan as she sat up and closed her eyes. She braced one hand behind her back onto Nicole’s abdomen while tangling the other through red locks, and pushed her pelvis forward as she grinded herself against Nicole’s face.

“Jesus, that’s so good baby.” Waverly leaned up a little and moved her hand from Nicole’s stomach to her hair beside her other hand, before almost immediately putting it back where it was before.

Nicole continued her movements around Waverly’s clit – but never directly touching it – spending the next few minutes slowly working her up, before finally wrapping her lips around the swollen bud and sucking as she simultaneously swiped the tip of her tongue back and forth across it.

Waverly’s hips jolted forward and her mouth dropped at the intense stimulation, and she felt herself hurdling towards her orgasm. She pressed her hand against Nicole’s engaged abs, digging her fingers into the exposed muscles and tightened her grip on Nicole’s hair as she rocked her hips fervently.

“Oh yeah, I’m so close baby.” She felt herself getting closer and closer to the edge as she picked up the pace of her moments, but just before she got there, Nicole pulled back.

“Fuck. Shit.” Waverly panted as she looked down at Nicole with confused eyes. “Why’d you pull away?”

“Because I want you to have a better orgasm than that. So I’m going to tease you a bit,” Nicole replied before slowly pushing her tongue out to touch Waverly’s clit, but as soon as she made contact and Waverly jerked her hips, she retracted it.

“Ugh, seriously? We don’t have time for this, Nicole.”

“We do if I say we do,” Nicole replied in a stern tone before sitting up and wrapping her arms around Waverly’s torso. “And in case it wasn’t obvious, I’m saying we do.” She immediately wrapped her lips around one of Waverly’s nipples and stimulated the taut peak before moving on to the other one.

Waverly closed her eyes and dropped her head back as she began to roll her hips again, needing some sort of stimulation on her sex. She didn’t care how wet she was, or that she was getting it all over Nicole’s stomach.

As soon as Nicole felt Waverly’s movements, she carefully guided the girl down onto the mattress with er head at the foot of the bed as she settled between her legs, moving her tongue in quick motions as she drew random shapes.

“Fuck fuck fuck fuck” Waverly repeated as the word continued to tumble from her mouth. She felt her sensitive clit twitching beneath the skilled movements of Nicole’s tongue, and she was almost instantly worked back up to where she had been before. “Shit. Holy shit, god fucking hell, please don’t stop. Oh my god, please. Ohhhh shit, yes baby!” Waverly balled the sheets in her hands on either side of her body as Nicole moved her tongue even faster. Waverly slowly lifted her back up off the mattress with her face contorted in pleasure as she felt the familiar tension building up. “Nicole, I’m gonna…”

Before she could even finish her sentence, Nicole immediately sat up between Waverly’s legs with her hands on the girl’s knees and a devilish grin spread across her stupid face.

“Nooo!” Waverly whined. “God dammit! Nicole, please!” She whimpered as she reached down between her legs, but Nicole grabbed both of her hands and pinned them above her head as she laid her body on top of the brunette’s.

“You’ll get to come, don’t worry. Just not yet. Be patient. I promise it’ll be worth it.” Nicole punctuated her sentence with a slow, tender kiss to Waverly’s lips, and the brunette relaxed her body down into the mattress.

Without breaking their unhurried kiss, Nicole entwined her fingers through one of Waverly’s hands above her head as she snaked the other hand down between their bodies. She lifted herself up a bit and slowly ran her two fingers through the slick folds, earning herself a gasp from the brunette into her mouth.

“Oh, god,” Waverly breathed as she moved her head back so that her nose was pointing up at the ceiling and dropped her jaw to suck in some air. She slowly rolled her hips in sync with Nicole’s steady movements of her fingers, simultaneously wanting more yet not wanting anything to change. The way Nicole was touching her – gently rolling her clit between the insides of her two fingers on either side with a little bit of pressure – was heavenly.

Waverly brought her free hand down to wrap around the back of Nicole’s neck, and she opened her eyes to meet sweet, loving ones. “Please baby. Please let me come,” she begged in a hushed tone. “I don’t want to wait anymore. I want an orgasm. Please, Nicole.”

The redhead looked down into begging eyes and slowly removed her hand to cup Waverly’s face. She smiled as she brushed her thumb back and forth along the girl’s strong jawline. “Okay baby.”

Nicole crawled down Waverly’s body, kissing every inch of her skin as she went, before settling between the girl’s legs. She stroked her tongue up through the wet folds a few times before drawing around the sensitive bud.

Waverly lifted her head to stare down into soft eyes as she gently brought her hand down to the top of Nicole’s head, where she held on for support. Her mouth repeatedly opened and closed as her eyebrows drew together and her muscles began to tighten. She felt warmth spreading throughout her entire body, causing a faint red to mix in with the golden tones of her skin.

Nicole smiled as she spelled out the words ‘I love you’ with her tongue on Waverly’s clit, before flicking it as quickly as possible across the bud.

Waverly promptly pushed her center up into Nicole’s face as she felt her entire body quake from pleasure, and Nicole responded by wrapping her lips around the brunette’s clit and sucking on it. An abundance of moans fell from Waverly’s mouth, echoing off the walls as she felt the intense contractions stemming from between her legs and shooting throughout the rest of her body. It felt like it was never going to end. She wasn’t sure if this was one really long orgasm, or multiple orgasms that just kept happening over and over again, but either way she was grateful for it.

When she finally felt her body relax underneath Nicole’s continued swipes, Waverly patted the woman’s head, and Nicole crawled up her body to give her a tender kiss on her forehead before dropping beside the woman to let her catch her breath.

Once Waverly felt like she could move again, she rolled on top of Nicole and settled her body between her legs as she laid on top of her and began kissing her. As soon as she started rolling her hips and licking one of Nicole’s nipples to get her worked up, Nicole shook her head with a small smile. She grabbed Waverly’s shoulder’s and urged her up, and the brunette looked at her with a lifted eyebrow.

“It’s okay. We don’t have much time. We have to leave in a few minutes.”

Waverly smirked as she sat up on her knees and ran her fingers through her own arousal, collecting it on her fingers. “I can be quick.” She immediately brought her coated fingers to Nicole’s clit and fervently moved them back and forth, hitting the right spot at just the right pressure.

“Oh, fuck” Nicole bent her knees up and spread her legs as she ran her hands all over her own body.

It was less than a minute later when she felt herself approaching her own orgasm. She smiled as she quickly sat up with one hand behind her back and the other wrapped around Waverly’s neck as she pulled the brunette into a heated kiss while hastily rocking her hips, causing the bed to bounce. As soon as she reached her climax, she released Waverly’s lips and pressed their foreheads together as she squeezed her eyes shut and cried out in pleasure. After she came down from her high, she slowly relaxed her eyebrows and opened her eyes to see Waverly’s right in front of her from their foreheads still touching.

“What do you say we skip the bar, and stay here and cuddle instead?” Nicole asked with a hopeful smile.

Waverly chuckled and shook her head as she brought her fingers up to her lips and sucked them clean before standing up next to the bed. “We can’t bail. Dolls needs our support. It sounds like he really likes this girl.”

Nicole groaned as she dropped back onto the mattress with her arms curved above her head, bouncing a couple of times from letting her body drop. “Fine.”

“But, maybe we can tell him we’re going to be a few minutes late. I want to take a shower so that it’s not obvious what we were doing right before we left.”

Nicole shot up into a seated position. “Can I join you? I think I need to wash off again too.” She grinned.

Waverly pointed a firm finger at her. “Fine, but just to bathe. No funny business.”

Nicole shrugged as she stood up from the bed and grabbed Waverly’s hand to excitedly drag her into the bathroom. “No promises.”

---

Waverly and Nicole walked through the front door of Shorty’s, hand-in-hand while sporting huge grins as they walked up to where Wynonna was standing behind the bar.

“What’s with your faces? Did you just get laid or something?” Wynonna asked with a quirked brow.

Waverly rolled her eyes as she slid into the stool beside Nicole. “Why does that have to be the only reason we’re smiling? Maybe we just watched a cute video of puppies going down the stairs for the first time. You don’t know...”

The older Earp narrowed her eyes as she slowly leaned over the counter and studied her sister’s face. “Because Dolls said he wanted us all to meet 20 minutes ago, and you’re always punctual. Even if puppies are involved.”

Waverly shrugged as she set her purse down on the counter in front of her. “Well, maybe we just lost track of time doing something else.” She looked around the bar as she avoided eye contact with Wynonna.

“Uh huh,” Wynonna replied with a look of doubt as she leaned back to her original distance before grabbing an empty glass and filling it with beer.

“So, where is Dolls anyways? Is he here yet?” Nicole asked as she gratefully took the beer Wynonna handed her without asking.

“Haven’t seen him yet. Probably late for the same reason you two were,” Wynonna snorted.

Nicole shrugged as she brought the glass up to her lips. “Probably.”

Waverly backhanded Nicole on the arm, causing her to almost spill her drink, as she gave Nicole a warning look.

Nicole just looked at Waverly with confused, innocent eyes before setting her glass back down on the counter.

“Oh, there he is. Finally.” Wynonna said as she nodded towards the door.

“Earps! Haught! Sorry I’m late. We lost track of time,” Dolls said in a cheery voice as he walked up to the group with a beautiful woman on his arm.

Nicole and Wynonna gave each other a knowing look before Nicole finally turned around to see this mystery woman for the first time. She was close to Nicole’s height, had curly, dirty blonde hair – it was obvious that it wasn’t her natural color, but suited her well – and was wearing a gorgeous dress. Nicole drew her eyebrows together as she narrowed her eyes. Something about the woman seemed familiar.

“Nicole, Waverly, Wynonna…I’d like you to meet—”

“Kathy?!” Nicole interjected in shock when she finally realized who the woman was. She sat in her stool with her chin practically in her lap, looking completely dumbfounded.

A surprised smile grew on the blonde’s face. “Nicole?”

Waverly furrowed her brow and immediately turned to look at Nicole. “Wait…Kathy as in the girl you slept with in high school?”

Kathy chuckled lightly as she casually folded her arms across her chest in disbelief. “Well, I guess that story’s not really a secret anymore.”

Waverly scowled at the woman, roaming her eyes up and down her seemingly perfect body. She couldn’t help but think about all of the things Nicole had done to that body…and all the things that body had done to Nicole.

“Holy shit, I feel like I’m in a lesbian soap opera!” Wynonna stated excitedly as she leaned against the counter, shaking her head as she looked up and down the blonde woman. “Damn Haught! This chick was your first?! No wonder you immediately knew you were gay!”

Waverly glared at Wynonna with dagger eyes and let out a low growl.

Wynonna cleared her throat and shook the disbelieving smile from her face. “I mean, I could really use some popcorn right about now. Or any salty snack, really. I’m not picky.” She shrugged before moving one hand to rub her belly and the other to rest on her lower back.

“Wait, what’s going on?” Dolls asked with his eyebrows knitted together in concern and confusion as he looked directly at Nicole.

Nicole immediately looked at Waverly glaring at her with her fingers practically digging into her hips, then at Wynonna looking at her with raised eyebrows and shoulders, then to Kathy who was standing there with an amused smile, and lastly to Dolls who was impatiently waiting for an answer. She swallowed thickly before finally opening her mouth to speak…

“I…”