CHAPTER 189

  Hailey's POV

  I could see Ian dying to chase after Liv as she ran down to the bathroom. Had I hurt her? Was Ian the thing she wanted but couldn't have, and I took it? I know he was her first love, the guy who meant a lot to her in high school. Did she harbor some feelings for him that I didn't know about?

  I looked over at Lucas, whose jaw was clenched hard enough to crack a tooth. Was this what they argued over? Ian? Is Lucas worried, too? I know Liv better than to think she would ever do anything with Ian. She loves Lucas with all of her heart, and she would never betray him like that. I could see that Lucas wasn't so sure of the fact, so as the best friend, it was my duty to make sure he saw she wouldn't.

  "Lucas, do you remember when you got into that accident on your way home? It was over a year ago now, and you broke your arm."

  "Yeah, of course I remember. I hated that cast so much," he replied while feeding Abi a bite of spaghetti. "What about it?"