​Chapter 8: Emphasizing Sincerity and Kindness for the Wolves' Benefit

"In my understanding, if Player 6 is the original jumper,"

"they should just jump in, finish their speech, and then focus on criticizing Player 2 as a key contradiction."

"That's all they need to do."

"Instead of not jumping themselves and letting Player 7 jump, while making it obvious they're signaling others."

"I don't think Player 6 would be that foolish."

We're all strangers here—why would Player 6 trust Player 7 so blindly?

When their own speech was so strong, why would they entrust their fate to Player 7?

That's simply against human nature.

"If Player 7 is the original jumper, then Player 6 could've just analyzed the situation upfront, saying they're tentatively siding with someone or need to hear more."

"Either approach would've worked, right?"

"I think in a life-or-death game like this, no one's a fool. Players like 5 and 6, who directly pick sides early on,"

"actually strike me as having solid mentalities."

"Player 8's skepticism toward 6 and 7 is pretty intense. I feel like they're putting in real effort."

"First, they say they're unsure, then analyze how 6 and 7 couldn't possibly recognize each other as allies—so they must both be wolves."

Honestly, this angle of argument is impressive. It aligns perfectly with Tian Lin's own thoughts.

For the good players, simply picking the right side is already a challenge.

"I believe logical reasoning and structured, persuasive speech are true skills."

"Take Player 6, for example—their delivery is smooth. They joke around but still make others feel their points are valid."

Tian Lin couldn't help feeling proud. Five years later, he was still being praised by players—it felt surreal.

"We can't dismiss a player as a wolf just because their logic is too polished, right?"

"At least I don't agree with Player 8's line of thinking."

"Good players in the lower seats should vote based on their own judgment. Don't let Player 8's theories sway you."

"I'm leaning toward Player 7."

Player 9's analysis during the pre-vote phase was thorough.

They seem like an intuition-driven player.

They're probably better at playing as a good citizen, accurately identifying sides.

This type of player excels at critiquing others, dissecting the rights and wrongs in speeches.

For now, Tian Lin tentatively labels them as leaning "good."

Overall, they didn't push any agenda for Player 2 this round, but their future votes and speeches need monitoring.

That's the nature of Werewolf: pre-vote speeches can be deceptive.

Wolves might lie low or charge ahead, but the final vote between the two prophets will expose them.

By then, few wolves can hide.

​​[Player 11's Speech]​​

Player 11, a middle-aged woman, begins:

"I'm not the prophet. I joined the pre-vote phase because I didn't want to vote blindly."

"I don't play Werewolf often—I watched all the tournaments during the 2018 craze."

"Then in 2030, I witnessed the rise of several amateur Wolf Kings."

Hearing this, Tian Lin glances up at Player 11.

He never imagined someone would remember his past.

The other players also glance between Tian Lin's username and Player 11's face.

All 12 players have heard of or watched Tian Lin's 2030 matches.

"My skills are limited, and I'm afraid of voting wrong."

"So I joined the pre-vote phase to listen first, then try to pick a side."

"Right now, Players 2 and 7 are claiming prophet."

"I genuinely can't tell them apart."

"I remember Wolf Kings like JY and Tian Lin once said: to identify the prophet, ignore other players' speeches."

"Because we can't fully grasp the wolves' strategies and coordination."

Surprisingly, someone still remembers his old advice. Back then, he'd livestreamed tips for newcomers.

But when his mother suddenly fell ill, he had no choice—livestreaming income wasn't enough.

He traded his Wolf King title for her treatment. Thankfully, she stabilized.

Tian Lin never regretted it. It was just a different path.

Even now, he'd make the same choice.

"Judging by independent speeches, Player 7 is stronger. But since Player 2 spoke first,"

"I want to hear Player 2's analysis of the pre-vote players, their take on the counter-claimant, and their breakdown of Player 6's speech before committing."

Though she claims to be inexperienced, she's the steadiest player here.

Listening to Player 11, Tian Lin feels a flashback to his competitive days.

He never thought he'd inspired others.

He never imagined returning to the scene five years later, still called a Wolf King.

"Let me analyze the others."

"Players 1 and 3 feel similar to me."

"Their speeches and attitudes seem solid, with no hint of being on a team."

"I'm not vouching for them—just noting their speeches lean good."

"Player 1 didn't make major points, but pressuring later players is a good move."

"The only wolf-like thing about Player 3 is their later 'golden water' claim, which could align them with Player 2."

"Player 4 is Player 7's golden water. Let's watch their vote."

"Players 5, 6, 8, and 9 have openly picked sides."

"I suspect at least 1-2 are wolves pushing aggressively."

Player 11's points are reasonable but surface-level—likely due to her lack of gameplay experience.

Still, her overall strategy is sharp, likely honed from years of spectating.

"The battle lines are clear now."

"If Player 2 is the prophet, wolves are among 6/7/9."

"If Player 7 is the prophet, wolves are among 2/3/5/8."

"If the lower-seat players are undecided, let's force a tiebreaker."

"Player 4 votes for 7, Player 10 for 2. Player 12, just abstain."

"Of course, if there's a wolf in the lower seats, you'd better follow my plan for a tie."

"Otherwise, voting against your wolf teammate might blow up your whole team, right?"

Tian Lin watches Player 11—she's mimicking his old tactics.

Gently advising wolves, teasing them, all while wearing an innocent mask.

Who knew this plain-looking woman could master his signature "sincerity for the wolves" act?

The livestream chat erupts:

"Oh my god, I'm tearing up—is this Tian Lin's superfan?"

"What a legendary auntie!"

"Let her talk more! Give her screen time!"

"She mentioned Wolf King Tian Lin—does he feel any guilt now?"

Tian Lin thinks Player 1 has been consistent. As the last pre-vote speaker, she analyzed everyone.

Her logic frames the wolf lineup differently.

She also directed the lower-seat votes.

Despite claiming inexperience, her skills are sharp.

Player 11's speech and actions lean good.

Hearing another round means both prophets speak on equal footing.

Universal voting minimizes wolves' influence on the sheriff race.

The vote itself will reveal perspectives, aiding future analysis and checks.

Tian Lin too hopes for a tiebreaker.