It's a-

VIVIAN

When Esmeralda and Beverly returned from their social outing, I could see that something was wrong. Beverly seemed uncomfortable, and kept glancing at Esmeralda and blushing. Meanwhile, Esmeralda seemed to be glowing, just like that time I smelled a man on her, only this time there was a cloud casting a faint shadow over her expression. I tried not to let my concern show on my face.

"Beverly, could you come help me out back?" I said.

"Okay."

Once we were far enough away that I was sure Esmeralda wouldn't be able to hear, I stopped.

"So what really happened when you went out just now?" I asked.

Beverly shifted uncomfortably.

"Nothing much. We just met with Esmeralda's friend."

"I already know that Esmeralda did more than just meet. I'm asking what happened to you."

Beverly squirmed under my gaze.

"Nothing, really. I just waited outside."

"And that's it?"

"She did invite me to join them, but I said no."