flood in like a nightmare: a terrifying fire tiger, a mysterious cave, and a slow, poisoned death. As Ryoma struggles to comprehend this new world, flashes of his own bloody past resurface—his wife and children slaughtered before his eyes, the king’s betrayal, and Artel’s sadistic grin.
Two bodies. Two tragedies. Ryoma must conceal his true identity—for now.
Strengths Engaging and Mysterious Opening The story begins with Ryoma awakening in a new and mysterious body, immediately raising questions that draw the reader in. This is a great element for building suspense. Blending Ryoma’s and Carter’s Memories The transition between Carter’s memories and Ryoma’s memories from his previous world is handled smoothly. The idea of the protagonist living in another’s body with a new past adds unique psychological depth. Rich and Coherent Fantasy World The features of your fantasy world—palaces, regions, empires, and special powers—are well-crafted, showing clear effort in world-building and attention to detail. Suspense, Excitement, and Escalation The progression from a simple mission to a major betrayal, and then to storming the palace and direct confrontation, gives the story strong momentum and keeps the reader constantly engaged. Visual and Emotional Descriptions The descriptions of the palace, guards, Ryoma’s clothes, and his emotional response upon discovering the betrayal are excellent. They make the reader feel as if they are witnessing the events firsthand. Suggestions for Improvement Clear Separation of Time and Place Shifts It’s better to use clearer breaks or subheadings such as “Ryoma’s Memories from His Old World” “Back in Carter’s Body” This helps the reader differentiate between past memories and the current events more easily. Clarify Character Motivations What’s the true reason behind the king’s betrayal? Was it a political move? Was he threatened by an external force? Adding these details will deepen the reader’s understanding of the plot. Avoid Repetitive Phrases Phrases like “Ryoma’s rage” or “his aura flaring” appear in various forms multiple times. Try to diversify the expressions to maintain freshness and impact in each paragraph. Use Dialogue to Reveal Details While the dialogues are good, they sometimes lean more toward exposition than interaction. Try to make the characters speak more naturally and emotionally, revealing their personalities through their words. Chapter Ending The chapter ends rather abruptly at a very suspenseful moment. It would be better to close it with a strong sentence or a clear cliffhanger, such as: “Ryoma’s voice, low and thunderous, cut through the silence like a blade...” Then cut the scene, prompting the reader to immediately want to continue to the next chapter. And I recommend reducing some of the wording in the chapter to make it flow better and improve its overall quality.[img=coins]